Home Blog Page 408

JP Nadda appointed BJP working national president

Rajya Sabha member and former health minister JP Nadda has been appointed as the working president of the Bharatiya Janata Party. He has been elected as Amit Shah has now taken charge as Union home minister though, for now, Amit Shah will remain BJP chief, but the workload will be shared with Nadda. In the previous government, Nadda was instrumental in furthering Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s flagship programmes including Ayushman Bharat.

The decision to appoint Nadda was taken in a BJP parliamentary board meeting which was chaired by PM Modi, BJP chief Amit Shah, and senior leader Sushma Swaraj among others. Speaking on JP Nadda’s appointment, Union Defence Minister Rajnath Singh said, “Amit Shah handled the responsibility of being BJP chief successfully for five years. Now that he has become home minister, he [Amit Shah] requested someone else take charge of the party. BJP Parliamentary board has selected JP Nadda as the working president.”

The 59-year-old Nadda, will be overseeing BJP’s election strategy for the upcoming state assembly polls in Haryana, Jammu and Kashmir, Jharkhand and Maharashtra. The BJP will likely get a new president by the start of next year.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi congratulated him in his tweet. “Shri @JPNadda is a diligent Karyakarta of the Party, who has risen through the ranks due to his hardwork and organisational skills. Humble and affable, he is widely respected across the BJP family. Congratulations to him on becoming the Working President of the Party.”

Mr. Nadda thanked PM Modi and Amit Shah on his twitter handle. “I will try to strengthen the party as its worker…serving the party is like worship for me,” he said.

Pakistan continues to breed terrorists on its soil. Modi is right in refusing talks with Imran Khan

With Indo-Pak relations plummeting to an all-time low, anything that can help end the acrimony between these two nuclear powers is most welcome. Perhaps this is why Pakistan’s Prime Minister Imran Khan’s repeated offer for re-commencing Indo-Pak dialogue to resolve all contentious issues has revived the clamour for positive reciprocation within political circles as well as a certain section of our intelligentsia. However, as the Indian government continues to maintain that terror and talks cannot go together, chances of the resumption of Indo-Pak dialogue in the foreseeable future seems quite unlikely.

Those who support reopening of Indo-Pak dialogue apparently draw inspiration from the old Chinese adage of how even a thousand mile long journey has to begin with a single step. These people are incurable optimists who aren’t demoralised by the fact that despite both countries engaging in a series of wide-ranging talks and instituting various Confidence Building Measures (CBMs) over a period of more than seven decades, differences between these two neighbours remain unresolved. The pro-dialogue school of thought strongly believes that even if talks haven’t delivered any positive result as yet, they haven’t had any negative effect either; therefore, there’s no reason to stop the harmless dialogue process.

But then there are others who maintain that the Indo-Pak dialogue process is nothing but a means to create a false illusion of peace and harmony with both sides ‘talking just for the sake of talking’. These people maintain that nothing ever comes out from Indo-Pak dialogues because Islamabad consistently refuses to walk its talk and therefore holding talks under these conditions is a waste of time, energy and money.

To support its viewpoint, the anti-dialogue camp cite instances of Islamabad’s treacherous response to New Delhi’s peace gestures, like Pakistan repaying Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee’s Lahore bus initiative to usher peace with the Kargil intrusions in 1999. They also remind us that it was Pakistan based terrorist group Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM) that attacked Pathankot air base just a week after Prime Minister Narender Modi’s personal gesture of making an unscheduled stopover in Lahore to personally wish his counterpart Nawaz Sharif on his birthday in an effort to promote Indo-Pak bonhomie.

One can always make light of those who are against Indo-Pak dialogue by dismissing them as ‘hawks’ or even calling them ‘war mongers.’ They can also be accused of doing great dis-service to the nation by promoting animosity and vitiating the environment, which makes any rapprochement well-nigh impossible. But despite this, it cannot be denied that these people are well-grounded in reality and refuse to be carried away by utopian illusions that peace and harmony will miraculously overcome deep-rooted hatred and suspicion created in the minds of people by their politicians on both sides of the Radcliff Line. Even though it may sound negative, but their stand against holding dialogue does make practical sense because what’s the point in siting down, exchanging pleasantries, announcing grandiose CBMs and making pretentious declarations pledging undying commitment to peace that won’t see the light of day?

Those who are in favour of dialogue feel that Imran Khan’s repeated offer for talks is a sign of his genuine desire to normalise Indo-Pak relations and therefore should be accepted by New Delhi. They also contend that since no Prime Minister of Pakistan can take the liberty of extending an olive leaf to India without explicit permission of the military, Khan’s repeated offers for dialogue must certainly be having Rawalpindi’s approval, making it a golden opportunity that New Delhi shouldn’t miss.

Some even say that Pakistan Army could well be goading Khan to talk with New Delhi as it wants to kill two birds with the dialogue ‘offer’. Firstly, it knows that resumption of talks would result in military de-escalation along the Indo-Pak borders giving Pakistan Army (which is at the receiving end of Indian Army’s strong retaliation to Pak Army initiated ceasefire violations along the Line of Control), a much-needed face saver. Secondly, Khan’s unilateral dialogue offer would also project Pakistan as a nation committed to peaceful co-existence with its neighbour and convey the impression to the world that it isn’t the army that’s calling the shots in Pakistan.

However, those who support the viewpoint that terror and talks cannot go together maintain that Islamabad is using the ‘dialogue card’ only to avoid being further isolated by the international community on its selective approach in tackling terrorism. This does make sense as Islamabad is desperately struggling to avoid being placed on the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) ‘blacklist’ for inadequate action to check money laundering and terror financing. So, should Modi accept or reject Imran Khan’s offer for talks?

To talk or not to talk with Islamabad-that is the question!  

By conveying that he is willing to address all contentious issues including terrorism and Kashmir, it may appear that Imran Khan is being extremely magnanimous and resolute in his efforts to usher peace in the region. But, by avoiding to make any commitment on reining in Pakistan based terrorist groups operating inside Kashmir, he has unwittingly confirmed that Islamabad doesn’t intend acting against terrorist groups enjoying state patronage and safe sanctuaries on its soil. While it appears that most pro-dialogue groups in India have apparently not seen through Khan’s devious plan and are continuing to press for recommencement of talks, Islamabad’s ploy hasn’t escaped Washington’s notice.

Washington has welcomed Khan’s offer for dialogue. But it has also listed certain critical issues that are essential for facilitating meaningful Indo-Pak dialogue as also achieving sustained peace, which buttresses the stand of the Indian government that ‘terror and talks cannot go together’.

Firstly, by saying that “underlying tension (between India and Pakistan) has been (due to) the role of terrorist forces that have sanctuary on Pakistani soil and this needs to be addressed,” the US has specifically apportioned the entire blame for strained Indo-Pak relations on Islamabad’s continuing patronage of terrorists. Secondly, by clarifying that “What the United States is really looking for in Pakistan are arrests and prosecutions and not allowing these (terrorist) groups to operate and move around freely, acquire weapons, cross into India, carry out attacks,” Washington has made it absolutely clear that the bottom line is dismantling terrorist infrastructure by Pakistan.

Thirdly, by stating that “Until these (terrorist) groups are put out of business, it’s going to be very difficult for India and Pakistan to achieve a sustained peace,” Washington has made it clear to Islamabad that as long as terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan isn’t dismantled, its yearning for peace and making offers for dialogue is just a charade.  Lastly, by mentioning that “the onus is on Pakistan to ensure that they crack down on these (terrorist) groups,” the US has left nothing to imagination. Therefore, though Khan may wax eloquent on his heartfelt desire to walk the extra mile to normalise Indo-Pak relations and willingness to talk on any issue, New Delhi shouldn’t budge from its principled position that terror and talks can’t go together as this isn’t a precondition but the pre-requisite for any meaningful dialogue!

Creating a better world with her love for animals

As per British novelist and poet Roald Dahl’s famous quote “Those who don’t believe in magic will never find it.” Shivani Gautam of Taimoor Nagar just found her ‘Magic’ in Connaught Place recently. An avid animal lover, 28-year-old Shivani recently rescued a puppy from a beggar, who was drugged and used as a bait for begging. As Police and NGOs refused to rescue the drugged puppy, due to the threat of beggar mafia, she decided to take action on her own, with support from a male volunteer. After severe resistance by the beggar, she was finally able to rescue the puppy and named her ‘Magic’, as she found her smile magical.

Describing about the incident, she says, “The drugged puppy was used for begging at Connaught Place. A girl named Deepti Sharma, reached out for help to Delhi Police and a few popular NGOs to rescue the puppy. Though Police reached at the location but did not act and since group of beggars were there, nobody from the NGOs wanted to enter into any argument with them. She then posted about the incident on facebook and pleaded to rescue the puppy held captive and drugged by a female beggar. I saw that post and went to CP the very next day with a volunteer. We tried to convince the lady beggar to give the puppy for a routine checkup. As anticipated, the lady denied and started being aggressive.” Finally, Shivani was able to rescue the puppy, after distracting the beggar and escaped from the market.

“The puppy was about 20-days-old and unable to walk because of the drugs and weakness without mother’s milk,” she noticed.  She fed the puppy and paid for her foster care, and now the puppy is healthy and will be soon adopted by a family.

Though ‘Magic’ was rescued by Shivani just few days back, but It was five years ago, when she was fighting her battle with fibroadenoma and struggling with the after-effects of lung bullectomy, that she stumbled upon her first rescue-an indie pup Jeeva. Meeting Jeeva changed her life forever. She saved the puppy after a severe accident and in that she found her biggest morale booster, to help fight her own health battles. Saving one puppy from road inspired her to follow the path of helping animals. “Saving animals and getting them treated, makes my job and house worth something”. Now, she clearly understands the pain of animals and is working to fight against animal cruelty. She turned to a vegan from a hard-core non-vegetarian, as she believes that all lives matter equally.

Shivani, who did her B.com from Gargi, College followed by a Masters in commerce from IGNOU, subsequently worked for a period of two years before she was diagnosed with fibroadenoma. She now mainly focuses on animal welfare, and also has an interest in learning Japanese and preparing for JLPT N3.  She has saved many puppies suffering from diseases like distemper and parvovirus. About 25-30 street dogs rely on her for their food and treatment. She also does advocacy for the pets, who are being mistreated and exploited by their owners.

She believes that saving animals gave her a purpose in life. She has rescued baby squirrels, motherless cats dumped in a dumpster during winter. She calls herself mother to her 7 Indies, who stay with her. Even though it’s hard to raise funds for treatment of animals and other expenses, she has never given up hope. Shivani believes in magic and also knows that it’s her action that will make this magic possible.

Conversation with Faisal Saeed Al Mutar on Ideas Beyond Borders

Faisal Saeed Al Mutar is the founder of Ideas Beyond Borders and Bayt Al-Hikma 2.0, Global Secular Humanist Movement. He is an Iraqi refugee, satirist, and human rights activist. He is also a columnist for Free Inquiry. Here, we continue to talk about the recent work.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: What is new? What is new within the mission and mandate of Ideas Beyond Borders?

Faisal Saeed Al Mutar: There are many things. I want to focus on a few. We have assembled a team of editors and translators to make many of the articles that were not available to be available on Wikipedia.

Only a small portion of the articles are available in Arabic, for a language spoken by more than 400 million people. We have successfully moved the Arabic language to the 16th. There is a lot of work to be done.

But I am confident in the team that is constantly growing. We have translated roughly one million words in less than 6 months. We have a team from all over the region who constantly are trying to fill in the missing elements or information.

That the closed societies try to deal with. We have secured a partnership with Wikimedia Levant. Wikimedia is the mother of Wikipedia and other projects. In partnerships with other wikis, we are able to issue certificates, so that they can advance in their own career.

That element of empowerment that we deal with. On other subjects, on the books, we have translated roughly 10 so far. We are acquiring more and more to be released in our digital library. It is designed by the company of WordPress itself, which has generously featured us in their campaign for doing anything.

For people interested, they have listed IBB as one of their success stories. They have designed our website. They are also designing our library website, which is Bayt al-Hikma 2.0. It will be where there will be most of the content in terms of books.

People can also go to IBB Wikipedia to see the list of articles translated and are translating. It is constantly growing. We are tapping it, to start new programs and features and more stories of some of the heroes – I would say. 

Those who are on the day-to-day basis fighting extremism, not necessarily with a gun. They are sharing a positive counternarrative that is enlightening and counter to the way the extremists tell us how the world is going badly – and the only way to change it is via extremist ideology.

It is why we are glad to have Stephen Pinker in the Advisory Board, who is about the counternarrative. It is Enlightenment values and a positive outlook. That the world is getting much better than the extremists show.

2018 was a tremendous year. It was a year of foundation, of trying to figure out who is who, building relationships, building partnerships, and so on. I see 2019 as the year of growth and constantly trying to expand our team, expand our network, expand our impact.

Our page grows roughly 1,000 likes a day. We have multiple social media managers working all across the region. Today, I got the statistics. We have roughly 5,000 likes from Iraq, 10,000 from Algeria, 7,000 from Egypt. We have an impact all across the world.

That impact is constantly increasing. I am pretty happy. This year is going to be the year of creating more content. As we also continue to do more on the ground, we have campus programs from last year expanding from the east coast to the west coast. 

We are partnering in the creation of workshops. Those are trying to fight extremism through culture, through arts, through positive ideas. Stephen Pinker on the AB said that ideas can change the world.

Extremism is an idea. It can change the world. We are trying to counter the narrative with a positive image. I am pretty excited about what is coming.

Jacobsen: If we are looking at the global threat of extremism and terrorism, according to the 2016 UN Arab Human Development Report within the IBB Annual Report 2018, what does this indicate about the Middle East-North Africa region and work IBB does in terms of education and other means?

Al Mutar: The development report is an important element. It is why we mentioned it in the report. For a region that is very small, it is a source of constant conflicts. It has produced a lot of attacks and a lot of refugees.

On The Rubin Report, I said, “The Middle East is like Las Vegas, but happens in the Middle East doesn’t say in the Middle East.”

Jacobsen: [Laughing].

Al Mutar: What helped as a pre-requisite, it is the language. It is helpful. We are developing these educational projects because many of the wars launched against the region have been dealing with the iceberg. 

Some have been dealing, even with the region defeat of ISIS, with a lot. I definitely celebrate the defeat. But the environment that permits groups like ISIS to exist is still there. The issue of extremism is multilayered, so is the issue of extremism. 

It is multilayered, so is the issue of terrorism. The ideological and ideas element is important. That is why I think we can have the most impact by making the ideas of the Enlightenment accessible in that region.

Russia has its narrative in the Arab world. The extremists have their narrative in the Arab world. There is no institutionalized narrative of Enlightenment in the Arab world. I think that is what IBB can do. That is what we have been successful in doing over the past year. 

I think we will continue to do that.

Jacobsen: In terms of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 19 speaks to freedom of expression, which is more general than freedom of speech – especially in an international context. 

How does arguing for freedom of expression as one of the most important rights stop the spread of extremism?

Al Mutar: That is a very good question. There is a distinction, in my mind, between conversation and violence. When conversation stops, violence, in general, is the only outlet that people use to justify the spread of their ideas and ideals.

If you look at many of the countries with censorship across the Middle East, you will see this in many extremist groups. Because when you censor or kill anybody who disagrees with you, as many of these dictatorships do, extremists and the people who do not care about life.

They will the only people to show disagreement and most often violently. We take freedom of speech for granted in the Western world. Even though, it is being challenged here. We always have to remember that the element of freedom of expression and combatting censorship in that part of the world.

It is an extreme element of combatting extremism. When people find a way to express themselves through outlets and newspapers, there can always be differences of opinion. I do not think people go to violence as the first route. 

I often think violence is the last resort. I think most issues can be resolved through conversation. It might be heated. It could be the dislike between people with different opinions. But I think the resort to violence will be much less if we allow all the other options for democratic participation.

People with the right to freedom of assembly, freedom of religion, freedom of thought. I was, recently, in a conversation with a representative from a Syrian group in Iraq. He was telling me for ages. Many of their Syrians have existed peacefully in Iraq. But many of them, because of the conflict, are picking up arms to defend themselves.

When there was a peaceful situation in which people were considered citizens and then there were no attacks against them, one of the oldest groups in Iraq have existed in peace and never resorted to violence.

Now, they are doing it, forming militias. When there is a conversation, when human rights are respected, when civil societies can participate and protect rights and advocate for these rights, then, definitely, something positive can happen here. It is a counter to extremism.

Jacobsen: What would be the biggest thing IBB can do, and other individuals and groups can support IBB in doing, in 2019 to further the advancement of the Article 19 right to freedom of expectation from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in addition to the empowerment of individuals on the ground in the Middle East-North Africa region who may not have access to rights and the information that people, such as ourselves, simply have as a privilege?

Al Mutar: One of the main things that we’re incorporating as part of our growth is building a global network. Building a global network has a lot of positives in which a lot of other people try to help other people achieve their goals, as I say, one of the main elements of IBB is the institutionalization and building the network.

There are many missing elements in the ideas world. There are many individuals working by themselves. They are not getting enough advice. Having one institution, it is allowing things to grow. As you can see, our AB is constantly growing.

This is in addition to the ambassadors and employees. All of these people, they work together. Everybody can play a major role, whether they can donate their skills within the getting involved section of our website or in donating money.

I think building the network is what makes IBB helpful. It is what has been missing in most of these networks. There have never been any successful attempts to bring a network together. I think IBB is doing this already.

I think it will do this successful more and more. I have seen more and more people from the region getting involved.

Jacobsen: If we look at individuals such as Malala Yousafzai, and other human rights activists, what is the importance of women coming forward and adding their voices and being given platforms to add their voices to this progressive work, human rights activism, and advancement of freedom of expression in the Middle East-North Africa region?

Al Mutar: Very good question, I think it is important. There is an Arab proverb that comes from poetry. If we empower women, then we empower the next generation. Women are also not just mothers. But they are also teachers, doctors, and all of that. 

If you look at one of the main things that extremists have been trying to express across the Middle East, they are the number one victim of extremism. One of the major conversations happening right now in Afghanistan is what would a Taliban return to Afghanistan look like.

Many people who have been writing articles and advocating the Taliban is women. Because they would be denied human rights by these terrorist organizations. Malala being one from the region. There are also many others across not just the Arab world but the Muslim world, even the whole world. It is to be involved, as a message, and organized.

I think IBB is definitely playing a role in that. Also, in terms of getting more people to know about these ideas, there are several issues in the region, because of the existence of patriarchy in the Muslim world. Males have to be educated.

Within our translation project, it counters some of these elements within societies. It is exposing many people across the region to the idea of women’s rights, human rights, and civil rights, too. We have done multiple campaigns about that.

These societies will start to become more open. Women, hopefully, will be beneficiaries of it. I think it is their fight as much as our fight as well. That struggle is the struggle against extremism.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Faisal.

Al Mutar: Thank you, Scott!

Image Credit: Faisal Saeed Al Mutar.

Sahitya Akademi announces Bal Sahitya Puraskar and Yuva Puraskar 2019

Sahitya Akademi has selected 22 writers for the Sahitya Akademi Bal Sahitya Puraskar 2019 and 23 writers for Yuva Puraskar 2019. The Executive Board of the Akademi that met in Agartala today, under the Chairmanship of its President, Dr. Chandrashekhar Kambar approved the selection of awardees. The Union Minister for Tourism and Culture (Independent Charge), Shri Prahlad Singh Patel congratulated the award winners. The awardees have been selected on the basis of recommendations made by the Jury comprising of three members each in the concerned language, in accordance with the rules and procedure laid down for the purpose.  According to the procedure, the Executive Board declared the Awards on the basis of unanimous/majority vote by the Jury.  Award in Maithili will be declared on a later date.

For the Bal Sahitya Puraskar, the Awards relate to books first published during the five years immediately preceding the year of Award (i.e. between 1 January 2013 and 31 December 2017). However, during the initial ten years i.e. from 2010 to 2019, the award may also be given to an author based on his/her total contribution to Children Literature.

Meanwhile, eleven books of poetry, six of short story, five of novel and one literary criticism have won the Sahitya Akademi Yuva Puraskar 2019. The Award relates to books published by an author of the age of 35 and below as on 1st January of the year of the award.

The Award in the form of a casket containing an engraved copper-plaque and a cheque of Rs.50,000/- will be presented to the awardees at a special function to be held at a later date.

For List of winners click here: http://164.100.117.97/WriteReadData/userfiles/PR-Sahitya%20Akademi(Bal&Yuv)%20final.pdf

HRD Minister asks VCs of Central Universities to prepare a blueprint to improve rankings

Union Human Resource development Minister Dr. Ramesh Pokhriyal ‘Nishank’ recently chaired a meeting with Vice Chancellors of all the Central Universities in New Delhi. Secretary, Higher Education Shri R. Subrahmanyam was also present in the meeting.

The Minister reviewed the progress and the best practices of the universities. He also reviewed the present infrastructure, maintenance and human resource related aspects. The Minister gave assurance to the chancellors to extend maximum support for the development of universities.

The Minister was concerned over the vacancies and directed UGC to develop a mechanism to fill them quickly, so that young generation may get quality education. Dr Nishank also urged that all universities should prepare a blueprint to improve rankings. The Minister hoped that by providing quality education and research, India can become world leader in the field of education.

The Minister said the Universities should focus on skill based and job oriented education to overcome the challenge of unemployment in the country. And he also congratulated the best performing universities for the good work.

Anantnag Terror Attack: India needs to strengthen internal security protocols

The killing of six soldiers of the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), an SHO (Station House Officer) of Jammu Kashmir Police and a civilian who sustained severe injuries during a suicide attack at Anantnag, Kashmir, has set alarm bells ringing in the security set up of Jammu and Kashmir, particularly Kashmir Valley. One of the two terrorists who carried out this Fidayeen (suicide) type of an attack was also gunned down while the second has managed to escape; a cordon has been put in place and he too will meet his fate in a matter of time. The attack is highly condemnable. The nation stands with the families of the martyred soldiers, the policeman and the civilian.

A fringe terrorist organisation, Al-Umar Mujahideen, has claimed responsibility for the attack. It owes allegiance to a Pakistan-based terrorist outfit said to be led by one Mushtaq Ahmad Zargar, who was freed by India along with Masood Azhar in the 1999 hijack incident. The terrorists are said to have used automatic rifles and grenades for the attack. Police has confirmed that the killed terrorist seems to be of foreign origin.

A detailed assessment of the incident raises certain issues with respect to the internal security policy and protocol being followed in Kashmir. Is it proper for security personnel to bunch up so closely that they are targeted effectively by two terrorists in broad daylight? How did the terrorists manage to get so close to the patrolling party? Why has the protective gear in terms of bullet proof jackets and bullet proof helmets not been able to take the brunt of the attack? One can understand injuries but outright casualties in this manner should be unacceptable to any professional commander, be it the Indian Army, the police or the paramilitary – as in this case.  

Both Omar Abdullah and Mehbooba Mufti have condemned the attack and expressed solidarity with the martyrs, which is good. One is reminded, however, of the time a few years back when they created a big scene about the security bunkers in urban areas and got them removed. Had the bunkers been there, many of these casualties could have been avoided.

The government has not come out with an official statement. Such an approach looks better than the “Kadi Ninda” (strong condemnation) of the earlier days but only if some firm action is taken on ground to address chinks in the armour. Somebody senior like the Home Minister or at least the National Security Advisor (NSA) should visit the encounter site personally to assess the situation and the cause behind the incident. Strong corrective action, including sacking of such senior officers who are found to be wanting in the implementation of strict security protocols and standard operating procedures, would send out the right message.

Precious lives of soldiers are being lost in Kashmir. While not letting down the pressure on terrorists it is also necessary to ensure that the casualty rate of own personnel is brought down. This is possible by upgrading the level of leadership, training, weaponry, protective equipment and intelligence. If we keep accepting own casualties they will never come down, immediate corrective action in this regard is absolutely necessary.

The incident has cast a shadow on the forthcoming Shri Amarnath Yatra for which security is of primary concern. It needs to be admitted that fool proof security is not feasible and incidents do happen, more often due to mistakes by the pilgrims rather than the security forces. Nevertheless, security arrangements for the Yatra are comprehensive enough. There should remain no doubt in anybody’s mind that the pilgrimage, with intensive preparation by the security forces and complete support of the locals, will be conducted in a safe and secure manner.

Next in analysis comes the external factor; since a Pakistan-based terrorist organisation has claimed responsibility, quite obviously, the planning would have been done in Pakistan. It is not clear whether the terrorists involved had been infiltrated recently or were already functional in the Valley. Either way, a terrorist initiated operation of this nature requires a lot of preparation and motivation which has been forthcoming from across the border. It becomes quite clear that terrorist organisations within Pakistan continue to be deeply involved in the spread of terror within India, especially Kashmir.

Under the circumstances, the initiative by Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan to press upon Prime Minister Narendra Modi the need to resume dialogue hold no locus-standi, since India has made it amply clear that terror and talks cannot go together. In any case, Pakistan has no intention to change the status quo so far as Kashmir is concerned; by offering talks it is merely trying to impress the global community. It is continuing with its attempts to place itself on a high moral pedestal in the global arena, not realising that the international community is exasperated with the continuous double speak. The international community is also very worried about the impact of the breeding of violence in Pakistan on the world at large and India in particular.

Not much can be expected from Pakistan, so it is best for India to get its own house in order leaving the neighboring country alone to rot in its deceit and treachery which is leading it to its own break up.

The terror machinery in Kashmir is on to its last breath as the intensive counter-terrorist operations over the last few years has broken its back bone. The terror masters in Pakistan are desperate to keep the agenda alive and with great difficulty they manage to engineer, once in a while, terrorist initiated incidents of the type that has taken place in Anantnag. While it is impossible to ensure zero casualties of own troops the same can be brought down considerably with better management. Commanders must remain sensitive of the fact that the dying terrorist is very dangerous indeed since he has got nothing to lose. It would be best to increase vigilance rather than the bravado.

J&K: Implement delimitation and have out of the box elections

Within days of the NDA (National Democratic Alliance) assuming office, Kashmir has taken centre stage. The situation there came up for discussion in the first meeting called by Home Minister Amit Shah. It has also been stated by the Election Commission that the State Assembly elections over there will be held only on culmination of the Shri Amarnath Yatra, which effectively would mean sometime in August-September at the earliest. The emerging situation gives to the government a window of opportunity for some out-of-the box thinking about the manner in which the election can be conducted.

Poor voter turnout has plagued the election process for some time now. Threats by terrorists and their supporters in the civil stream is the single big reason behind this malaise. There is enough time to invoke use of technology to ensure that the voters in Kashmir can vote from home — a process of electronic voting that links the Voter ID Card to an App can be evolved. Alternatively, mobile voting booths that go house to house to get the voting done without any security risk can also be considered. Enough security personnel are available for conduct of such an exercise. The idea is to get the voter to vote, even if he/she opts for NOTA (None of the Above). In fact, the electronic option can also be extended to the occupied territories (Pakistan Occupied Jammu and Kashmir).

It is understandable that the measures will be a deviation from the established process, but then, extraordinary circumstances call for extraordinary measures and Kashmir does fall in the extraordinary category. Elections in the Jammu and Ladakh region can be held in the traditional manner.

Delimitation is a second issue that needs to be considered before the elections are declared. There are rumours doing the rounds that the issue has been flagged by the state unit of the BJP to Home Minister Amit Shah and that it came up for discussion in the meeting at the MHA (Ministry of Home Affairs). Even though the government has gone on record to say that it has no intention of going through the delimitation exercise in the short term, the rumour was enough to propel the so-called mainstream leadership of Kashmir into hyper mode in building the usual doomsday scenario if the exercise is conducted.

The very fact that this segment of Kashmiri leadership, that has long since lost its relevance, is speaking against delimitation so strongly is reason enough for the exercise to be carried out without delay. It is so because these dynastic politicians think of self preservation first and foremost, the good of the people never factors in their scheme of things. If they are against delimitation, it can be taken for granted that the exercise will be disastrous for them and good for the people. NDA-3 should, therefore, move ahead with all guns blazing, while keeping legal sanctity in mind. 

The process of delimitation was carried out in J&K in 1995 and the next round was slated for 2005, since it has a ten year cycle. But, in 2002, the ruling National Conference Government froze delimitation until 2026 by amending the Constitution of the State. As things stand now the State Legislative Assembly has 87 seats of which 46 are from Kashmir, 37 from Jammu and 4 from Ladakh. For the Parliament there are two constituencies in Jammu, three in Kashmir and one in Ladakh.

The J&K state, with the Indian Union, comprises of 101387 sq. km area. Of this, Kashmir comprises only 16% of the landmass whereas Jammu and Ladakh cover a geographical area of 84%, the largest portion being Ladakh. Kashmir has on paper approximately 10% more population than Jammu, but it is so because lakhs of voters in Jammu region like the West Pakistan Refugees and those belonging to the Valmiki / Gorkha community, who have been living in the state for decades, have not been granted citizenship by successive Kashmir-centric governments. Also, lakhs of Kashmiri Pandits who have their votes registered in Kashmir are no longer living there but in the Jammu region and elsewhere across India. A correct census would take the population figure in Jammu beyond that of Kashmir.

The aforementioned data clearly indicates that the state has an unwarranted concentration of power in one region (Kashmir) and consequent lack of representation of the remainder two regions (Jammu and Ladakh) despite they being more significant in the terms of area as well as population.

The need for early process of delimitation in Jammu and Kashmir, which has been stalled by Kashmir-based vested interests through unjustified brute force in the Legislative Assembly, has since long been established. Non-conduct of this very relevant democratic exercise has marginalised the regions of Jammu and Ladakh in a manner that goes against all democratic tenets.

Be that as it may, all decisions on Kashmir will need to be taken with due caution and deliberation. Media has started building a Demi-God like persona of Amit Shah and has gone into overdrive in an attempt to give some deep interpretation to the first meeting that he has chaired. It is important for the government to break this myth and give out a clear message that the Home Minister will not be running a one man show in Kashmir; he will simply be pursuing the policies laid out by the NDA in its first term and such changes that are agreed upon collectively for implementation during this tenure. For example, NDA-2 had a very clear and potent policy of zero-tolerance towards terrorism and had given a free hand to security forces to deal with these criminal and anti-national elements. The policy has accrued very good results over the last year and a half. The new Home Minister simply has to keep the momentum going. He will not single-handedly sweep all terrorists in the River Jhelum, as the media would like to suggest. Such rhetoric is not something that the government should encourage since it will unnecessarily create distrust and adversely affect the process of normalcy, which is so important for the conduct of successful elections in the state.

Delhi’s Khirki village: Home for Afghani refugees

As temperature in Delhi hovers around 50 degree Celsius, Farid Khan, from Kabul, Afghanistan, longingly cherishes the pleasant weather of his homeland. “It never used to be so hot there,” he says, sitting in the corner of a narrow lane in Khirki extension, an area that has become no less than ‘little Kabul’, with the presence of thousands of Afghan refugees in the locality. In the tapered lanes, just opposite one of Delhi’s most expensive malls, the colours and aroma of Afghani culture and cuisine, provides a welcome respite from the cacophonous muddle in the area.

From Afghanistan to India

Most of the Afghani residents in the South Delhi village of Khirki Extension have been settled here by UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees), while some come here to avail cheaper treatment facilities in Delhi. Khambar Ali, a 66-year-old man from Mazar-i-Sharf, is in Delhi from last one month, for his knee joint surgery. He talks about the scarcity of medical facilities and supplies in Afghanistan. His mother also had a spine surgery at a city hospital here. In his homeland, he has been working as a driver for 40 years, and will be leaving for his home in a month, after the completion of his treatment.

Farid Khan (46) from Kabul and Khambar Ali (66) from Mazar-i-Sharif

But for thousands of others Afghanis in the area, it’s no less than a home now. Farid khan, 46, runs an Afghani cuisine restaurant in the basement of a building. He came to Delhi from Kabul, seeking shelter in 2010. He moved here with his children and wife. “I think of Delhi as my home now, I get everything here which I used to get there, what I don’t get here is my mother, whom I don’t get to meet,” he says. His mother stays in Kabul, with his brother’s family. When asked, if he gets a chance to go back to his homeland, he says, “Delhi is my home now, as it gave me shelter when I needed it. I have many friends here now. I don’t want my children to go through the same hardships, and hope they would make a decent living in India.”

Wahid-Ullah, 46, also runs a small shop in the area. He recalls how in 2014, things started worsening in his home town and he had to move to Delhi for shelter with the help of UNHCR, with his three children and wife. He is waiting for the day, when UNHCR will take him back to his home-land and when peace will return in Afghanistan.

Partners Sayed and Hamid, who run Green leaf restaurant in the area, recalls the time when his friend was injured in an explosion and lost his arms and legs. He used to work as a sales manager in a telecommunications company in Kabul. He used to fear for his and his family’s life every day before leaving for work and one day decided to move to Delhi, where already some of his relatives were living.

While for most of them physical displacement led to several hardships, but gradually, they have been able to establish a stable life and are hopeful of a better future for their next generation. Abdul Ma-an 18, son of the owner of Malviya Nagar’s popular Afghani outlet, Afghan Restaurant, who  is from Mazar-i-Sharif, moved here when he was 10 years old with his family. Currently, he is studying in a public school in the area. He recalls the tale told by his father, about his struggle with the language and no place to live. He wants to complete his graduation and help his father in his business.

Foodies’ Delight

Lanes of Khirki village adores an aromatic flavor, thanks to the traditional cuisine of Afghanis. Wahid-Ullah, is brilliant in making tandoori naan in the Afghani style, which is best served with tea. He has many regular Afghani customers who take his bread. He talks about how every Afghani household had a tandoor in it.  Farid’s restaurant also serves afghani delicacies and is an absolute treat for food lovers. While working on tandoor, he says Kabuli pulao, chopan kebabs, karahi shinwari chicken are the must-try food here. Green leaf restaurant, another Afghani cuisine based restaurant run by two partners Sayed and Hamid, also serves Kabuli pulao and kebabs as specialty. He plans to expand the reach of afghani cuisine to other areas of Delhi. For teenager Abdul Ma-an, the specialty of his father’s restaurant is murgh mussallam, whole chicken with skin is marinated with spices and then grilled on low flame for 3-4 hours.

It’s an altogether different world out here. Though, quite naturally, many of them still yearn for their motherland, but the warm and welcoming Afghani’s have made Khirki their new home. Their hardships have given them a new spirit to start life afresh and they look towards a promising future for their children.

(Photographs by Shrikant Kukreti)

Odia people held hostage in Sharjah: Dharmendra Pradhan writes to MEA

Taking cognizance of a group of people from Odisha forcibly locked in Dubai, Minister of Petroleum and Natural Gas, Dharmendra Pradhan, has written to the Minister of External Affairs, S. Jaishankar for swift action. In his letter, Pradhan wrote “I come across on OTV News report dated 30.05.2019 regarding some Odia people who are stranded in Dubai. On further enquiry it is revealed that 10 people who were working in the company Asia Pacific Building Contracting LLC, Dubai and accommodated at Sajja, Sharjah are kept captive.”

As per the letter, the people held hostage had also released a video; about a month back, asking for help for their immediate repatriation. However, their mobile numbers were now deactivated. “It has been ascertained that these men belong to Nayagarh and Ganjam districts of Odisha. A select few documents namely copy of the passport of one person Shri Pratap Maharana, Phone No. of one person as 971588957816, a copy of commercial license of the company etc. are available. Copies of these relevant documentary proofs are enclosed herewith for ready reference. Further it is stated that District Labour Officer of Nayagarh has also visited the house of some of the victims, however there is no progress in the matter yet. The request is for immediate repatriation of these victims to India,” he wrote in the letter.

The minister requested for personal intervention of the Minister of External Affairs and take up the matter with the concerned officials for early release of these people on humanitarian grounds.