Home Blog Page 437

What’s Next for Pakistan?

Wing Commander Abhinandan is back. One Pakistani F16 has been shot down and their pilot killed. Pulwama has been avenged with the destruction of the Jaish-e-Mohammad terror camps. And our apologists are back to hankering for immediate commencement of peace talks. Where’s the India-Pakistan relationship headed and what happens next for Pakistan?

After the Pulwama attacks there was a complete sense of gloom and doom in the country and everyone wanted revenge. Within a few days sarcastic comments were being made by leaders of the opposition. Twelve days later, the Indian Air Force hit back hard and destroyed three Jaish-e-Mohammad training camps in Pakistan and killed around 350 terrorists who were being trained. Also killed were 25 leaders of the terrorist organisation. It is interesting to note that it is primarily “family” members of Azhar Masood who were in leadership positions (no other meanings intended here)!

These strikes were applauded all over the country. It was surprising that while every opposition leader congratulated the Indian Air Force which was their due, not one of these politicians acknowledged the strong decision making by the Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Ironically, after making so much noise about the attacks, these political parties are now blaming the BJP for politicising the IAF action.

The following day, Pakistani F16 fighter jets tried to enter Indian air space and were rebuffed. One of these modern jets was shot down by Wing Commander Abhinandan who had been taken into custody. Under the Geneva Convention and after a lot of behind-the-scenes diplomacy and political manoeuvre, he has been released and back as a war hero.

So why are some sections of the press suddenly swinging to the other side?

Why has Imran Khan become a diplomat par excellence and what makes so many of our journalists and opposition politicians give so much credit to Pakistan.

  • It surprises me that some sections of the press have started to comment on why war is never an answer. Quite an inane set of platitudes because no one can deny this. But when you see how much hurt has been caused to our nation over the years by Pakistan supported terrorists, are these journalists talking about pulling back and going back to status quo ante?
  • Some journalists are questioning why the Prime Minister is going about his normal work day. Why shouldn’t he? I am sure he is monitoring the situation closely and has a team of excellent leaders who are more directly handling the matter. The same journalists would take the counter view if the Prime Minister was seen to be spending all this time on this matter.
  • Some journalists have asked whether India has a Defence Minister? I was not able to understand this comment. In addition to the Defence Minister and the National Security Advisor, there are three Chiefs of Staff and it is this core team that must be handling every detailed issue under the direct supervision of the Prime Minister.
  • Some politicians are screaming that all political activity must be stopped by PM Modi. Have they stopped all political activity from their side? The answer is a clear No.
  • One senior BJP leader has announced how many seats his party will win in a state. I think this is a very insensitive comment and must be condemned at all costs.
  • Then there is the Chief Minister of a major state who can’t stop talking about how this entire Pulwama episode has been stage managed by the ruling party. This thinking needs to be condemned in the strongest possible terms. It only shows the thinking of this Chief Minister.

I would strongly urge that we should let our elected Government do its work. 

On the other hand, Pakistan is in serious trouble.

Islamic Terror modules spread across Pakistan and in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir
  • Their economy is bankrupt, and though they are receiving some money from United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and China, all this money is coming with strings attached. There is no free lunch and some day payment will be extracted from Pakistan for today’s largesse.
  • Prime Minister Imran Khan is a puppet of the powerful Pakistan Army whose single point agenda is to keep war mongering against India. They have no other reason to exist.
  • Pakistan has created trouble on all its borders with Iran, Afghanistan and India. Its all-weather friend China only looks at a selfish financial partnership on account of the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).
  • No investors are willing to come and invest in Pakistan.
  • Despite so many promises, no credible action is expected to be taken by Pakistan against the terrorist camps being supported by their Army.
  • Finally, the Pakistan Army will continue to have a stranglehold on the country and every time a politician attempts to raise his head, they will either cut it or control it.

The last word has not been written on this subject. The last bullet has not been fired and the last life has not been lost. This is a long battle which has scarred many and will continue to scar many more.

Pakistan needs to take some serious confidence building measures which would include:

  • Allowing China to declare Azhar Masood as an international terrorist and hand him over for trial.
  • Hand over Hafiz Saeed to India to stand trial for the 26/11 Mumbai attacks of 2008.
  • Hand over Dawood Ibrahim, the architect of the 1993 Bombay attacks. (Bombay is now officially know as Mumbai. The name change happened in 1995)

Handing over these three terrorists would be a starter but given popular opinion, it is highly unlikely that the Pakistan Army will ever agree to handing over their prime terror arm.

Yet, it’s only after these actions have been taken should Pakistan ask for a dialogue on Kashmir.

It is too early for us to forget Pulwama and it is unrealistic to expect everyone to forgive and move on.

As the old saying goes we must forgive if Pakistan takes action against the terrorists, but we must never forget the harm they have caused us.

Punjab CM urges Pakistan to release all POWs of the 1971 War

Extending a warm welcome to Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman on his return home, Punjab Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh has urged Pakistan to release the Prisoners of War (PoWs) still in its captivity from the 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War.

In an informal chat with media as part of his tour of the border areas in the wake of the escalating tensions at the LoC (Line of Control), the Punjab CM also urged the Indian government to take up the issue with Islamabad.

Expressing happiness that talks to further thrash out the modalities for the Kartarpur Corridor were on track despite tensions, Captain Amarinder Singh requested New Delhi to allow 5,000-10,000 pilgrims to cross through every day once the corridor it becomes operational. He recalled his own family’s close connect with the Kartarpur Gurdwara, which his grandfather Bhupinder Singh had helped rebuild after the 1928 floods.

On the issue of compensation to people whose land was being acquired for the Corridor, Captain Singh said the state government will thrash out the matter with union government.

He hoped that tensions along the border are resolved soon and Sikhs across the globe get the opportunity to have ‘Khule Darshan Deedar’ of the historic Kartarpur Sahib Gurdwara with the fast completion of the Corridor. He added that he would be the first one to cross the border to pay his obeisance at the historic Gurdwara.

Kashmir challenges have increased manifold

It needs to be understood that Pakistan is equally determined to derail the political and security threshold in its quest to keep Kashmir on the boil. The situation requires enhanced vigilance and preparedness to meet unexpected challenges in the entire state of Jammu and Kashmir, especially the Kashmir Valley.

Wing Commander Abhinandan has been returned by Pakistan to India. There are divergent reasons being given for this decision by Pakistan but courtesy demands that we ignore the supposed ulterior motives and look for something positive in the development. It is a reason for celebrations and also reason to acknowledge the release as a good gesture on the part of the Imran Khan, in accordance with international norms. It is notable here that the escalatory threshold between India and Pakistan (both nuclear powers) had reached critical levels in a manner that caused apprehensions of all an out war under a nuclear cloud.

Now, with release of the pilot, attempts are on to bring down the tensions.

The release, however, has not had any impact on the situation along the Line of Control (LOC) and the hinterland in Jammu and Kashmir. Even as the return of the Wing Commander was underway, heavy firing was reported all along the LOC which has led to some civilian casualties. A massive counter-terrorist operation at Kupwara was also underway that witnessed the killing of two terrorists and also the unfortunate martyrdom of four security personnel and one civilian.

Cross LOC firing has been going on incessantly since the aerial attack by India on terrorist modules in Pakistani territory on February 26 that led to the destruction of three terrorist camps. Pakistani troops have been firing their Mortars and Missiles from civilian houses, using villagers as human shields. The Indian Army, however, has been targeting the Pakistani posts away from civilian localities. Pakistan had also unsuccessfully attempted to enter Indian air space in the sector with its sophisticated F-16 aircraft but the attempt was thwarted by the Indian Air Force with destruction of one Pakistani aircraft.

The writing on the wall is very clear. No let down in the Pakistani involvement in Jammu and Kashmir can be expected despite the so-called “grand” gesture of returning Wing Commander Abhinandan. There may be some de-escalatory movement between the two countries at the national level but it is unlikely to impact the conflict situation in Jammu and Kashmir.

The political development in the Kashmir region is also witnessing some paradigm shifts in policy. The crackdown on the Jamaat-e-Islami leading to arrest of its members followed by its ban has raised hackles of the political establishment in the Kashmir Valley. Hurriyat and even mainstream leaders have spoken against this action by New Delhi thus indicating creation of a fragile political situation. There are rumours that the Hurriyat too may face a ban. The government may go in for simultaneous elections for the state as well as parliamentary constituencies. Conduct of elections in Kashmir is a challenging process and such a scale will add to the security and administrative burden.

The Indian Army is sensitive to the emerging challenges and it is for this reason that the senior commanders of the Northern Command are visiting and interacting with their troops regularly, while making on-ground assessments of the situation to ensure that the preparedness is in order. Even as firing from across the border was underway, Indian Army’s Commander of the Northern Command, Lt. Gen. Ranbir Singh, accompanied by the Corps Commander was visiting the forward posts in Poonch. He took a detailed briefing on the actions taken to meet the challenges of increased ceasefire violations through superior and aggressive domination of LOC by the troops, in accordance with the policy to give a befitting reply to Pakistani transgressions. 

While considering the root cause for the escalation of the situation to such dangerous levels as has been witnessed in the last few days, the finger points, first and foremost, towards the Pakistan Army. It is a sinister, ruthless demon that is out to devour all that comes its way in a devilish pursuit for power. The Pakistan Army has long since shed tenets of honourable military norms and is quite content in converting poor, uneducated civilians of its country into cannon fodder, to be wasted without remorse in order to “bleed the Indian forces.” In this evil design it is being assisted by unscrupulous and mercenary warlords like Masood Azhar and Hafiz Saeed who run killing machines under their patronage.

Sadly, there are some in Kashmir who have also sold their soul to the devil and help in fructification of these evil designs. Young Kashmir boys are being indoctrinated and exploited to follow the self destructive path of terrorism by these elements. The recent crackdowns are a valiant attempt by the government to check this malaise.

The government of India should not reduce the pressure that has been built up against Pakistan and its proxies in Kashmir. To relent now would mean losing the initiative and the lost ground will be very difficult to cover in future. Pakistan simply has to be exposed for the evil that it perpetrates with impunity even as Kashmir is cleansed for its debilitating and destructive influence. The first step should be to put our own house in order for which action at the political and operational level is underway, simultaneously, there should be no let-down in exposing Pakistan in front of the international community. Preparations for a military face-off should gain momentum while enhancing existing security protocols.

It needs to be understood that the enemy is equally determined to derail the political as well as the security threshold in its quest to keep the region on the boil. The situation requires enhanced vigilance and preparedness to meet unexpected challenges in the entire state of Jammu and Kashmir, especially the Kashmir Valley. The security forces, led by the Indian Army, will have to usher peace and build an environment conducive for the conduct of free and fair elections, notwithstanding the attempts to derail the same.  It is quite apparent that the challenges to the security forces operating in the region, especially for the Northern Command of the Indian Army, have increased manifold.

Imran Khan’s “Peace Gesture” is a Big Bluff

Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan’s announcement that Wg Cdr Abhinandan Varthaman, the Indian Air Force (IAF) pilot, in its custody would be repatriated to India is good news. But only incurable Pakistan apologists (and of course the ignoramus) will believe Khan’s assertion that this release was being done as a “peace gesture,” because fact of the matter is that Islamabad had just no other choice whatsoever but to do this.  So while Congress leader Navjot Sidhu has rightly tweeted that a “nation rejoices,” but to hail the announcement made by Imran Khan that the IAF pilot’s release was a “goodwill gesture” is not only totally misleading but also completely inappropriate and downright gross. But there’s no need to get unnecessarily upset because it could well be the fertile comedian in Sidhu that has made him come out with such a hilarious tweet !

Geneva Conventions of 1949 lays down comprehensive instructions related to armed conflicts and Wg Cdr Abhinandan’s case comes well within the purview of this convention. Anyone conversant with its protocols will agree that Islamabad (which is a signatory to this convention) failed to ensure adherence to mandatory instructions contained in Convention III, which concerns issues related to treatment of prisoners of war (POWs). In its exuberance to humiliate the IAF pilot and hurt public sentiments in India, the Pakistan Army put a video on social media in which a crowd of civilians were seen mercilessly manhandling Wg Cdr Abhinandan while an armed Pakistan Army soldier pleaded meekly but did nothing to stop this physical abuse. This is in clear violation of Article 3 (a), which required Pakistan as the ‘detaining power’ to prevent any “violence to life and person” under its detention.

Furthermore, Pakistan was duty bound by Article 3 (c) of the Geneva Convention to protect the IAF pilot from “outrages upon personal dignity, in particular, humiliating and degrading treatment.” So, was it so urgent to present to him blindfolded and bound like a dangerous criminal before the media in a disheveled state with blood clots and grime on his face? First of all the Pakistan Army had no reason to vulgarly display Wg Cdr Abhinandan as some sort of ‘war trophy’. Even if the Generals couldn’t resist this temptation, couldn’t they at least ensure that his wounds were tended to, his blindfold was removed and he was unbound before being produced before the media? What has happened cannot in any way be passed off as an inadvertent faux pas; au contraire, it is abundantly clear that this was done on purpose with a perverse intent.

By saying “I want to now address India and say let sanity prevail. Let’s think sensibly. All wars in the world have been started on miscalculations on the time and the human cost of war,” Imran Khan may be attempting to sound like a great statesman and man of peace. But he has to give some very serious explanations as there is a wide disparity in what he is saying and what his armed forces are doing.  So if Khan sincerely doesn’t want the situation to escalate then he needs to explain the following:

  • When the IAF restricted their attacks to terrorist camps only, then why did his office announce on Tuesday that “India has committed uncalled for aggression to which Pakistan shall respond at the time and place of its choosing”?
  • Since he accepted that Wednesday’s violation of the Line of Control (LoC) by Pakistan Air Force (PAF) fighters was “only intended to convey that if you can come into our country, we can do the same, ” wasn’t this an immature act that could enhance the risk of further escalating tensions?
  • If the intention of air space violation by PAF was only symbolic as Imran Khan goes on to claim then why did DG ISPR Maj Gen Asif Ghafoor confirm that on Wednesday “Our planes locked targets; then in open air we carried out strikes”? Doesn’t such an aggressive action increase the risk of escalation?

The truth is that Imran Khan had no other option but to return Wg Cdr Abhinandan since the Pakistan Army badly messed up this case. Though Pakistan Army chief Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa has been repeatedly telling the world that there were no terrorist camps on its soil, the IAF air strikes against Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM) terrorist camps has exposed Islamabad’s duplicity in its war on terror. For Imran Khan the situation was absolutely hopeless, while Pakistan’s long “all weather friend” chose to distance itself, France volunteered to move United Nations Security Council (UNSC) for declaring JeM chief Masood Azhar a ‘global terrorist’. Even the Organisation for Islamic Cooperation (OIC) did not buckle under Islamabad’s threat of boycotting the foreign secretary meet in protest against India being invited as ‘guest of honour’.

One is not sure whether Imran Khan is genuinely keen to normalise relations with India, but then in a country where the military calls the shots, such feelings don’t matter at all. The reality is that there is no letup in spate of ceasefire violations along the LoC and this confirms the bitter but well known fact that Rawalpindi has no intention of giving peace a chance. In fact, PAF’s intrusion on Wednesday appears to be much more than just a show of strength as the Pakistanis claim. As reports have now revealed, it was supposed to be a massive retaliation by more than 20 combat aircrafts that was effectively thwarted by our alert air warriors. Why I’m convinced about this is because it’s inconceivable that Pakistani armed forces which never cease praising themselves for their exceptional professionalism would be so naïve as to violate the airspace of a hostile neighbour in a retaliatory act and then like school children get their thrills by carrying out airstrikes in “open air”.

Tailpiece: Wg Cdr Abhinandan’s release is the result of India’s refusal to make any compromises and its determined military and diplomatic pressure on Pakistan. Therefore, it is absolutely clear that both Imran Khan and his army chief Gen Bajwa are merely using the “peace gesture” explanation for this release as a ‘fig leaf’ to protect their political and professional modesty respectively.

India presents evidence of Pakistan’s missile attack


Joint Presser by India’s Military was addressed by Air Vice Marshal  RGK Kapoor (left), Major General Surinder Singh Mahal (middle) and Rear Admiral Dalbir Singh Gujral (right). Senior officials from the three wings of Indian Military came out at the joint press conference to dispel false propaganda unleashed by Pakistan Army and its rogue intelligence agency– ISI.

(Photo: PTI)
Indian Air Force officials point to the specific signature of the Amraam (Advanced Medium-Range Air-to-Air Missile) that was fired by Pakistan’s F-16 . (Photo: PTI)

IAF: No goodwill gesture, Pilot’s release in line with the Geneva Convention

Representatives of the Indian Air Force, the Army and the Navy, conducted a joint media briefing today and shared that armed forces are on high alert and ready to meet any security challenge on land and sea.

The Indian Air Force said it is very happy that captured pilot Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman is returning home but dismissed suggestions that it was a goodwill gesture, insisting it was in line with the Geneva Conventions. “We are very happy Abhinandan will be freed tomorrow and look forward to his return,” Air Vice Marshal R G K Kapoor, assistant chief of Air Staff, told a news conference.

Asked if the IAF sees it as a goodwill move, he said, “We see it as a gesture in consonance with the Geneva Conventions.”

Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan announced in Parliament on Thursday that Varthaman would be released on Friday as a “peace gesture”

Tensions between the two countries escalated after Indian fighters bombed terror group Jaish-e-Mohammed’s biggest training camp near Balakot deep inside Pakistan early Tuesday. It came 12 days after the JeM claimed responsibility for a suicide attack on a CRPF convoy in Kashmir, killing 40 soldiers.

Pakistan succumbs to India’s diplomatic offensive, will release pilot Abhinandan

Pakistan succumbed to intense international pressure and diplomatic offensive launched by India as it agreed to release Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman.

Imran Khan, Pakistan’s Prime Minister, made an announcement in the Parliament of Pakistan. He said that they are willing to release the Indian pilot tomorrow.

Yesterday, Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman had successfully shot down Pakistan’s F-16 that had intruded into Indian airspace. However, he had to eject his Mig-21 when it was struck by retaliatory fire and had landed in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. He was then captured by Pakistan Army. India then launched massive diplomatic offensive and was successful in isolating Pakistan. All major powers of the world including the US, France, UK, Saudi Arabia and even China directed Pakistan to follow Geneva Convention on Prisoner’s of War (POW).

That Pakistan was under intense international pressure was evident when today morning US President Donald Trump had said that there would be some “reasonably decent news” on the ongoing conflict between India and Pakistan. “They have been going at it and we have been involved in trying to have them stop,” Trump said. “We have been in the middle trying to help them both out.”

In a face saving gesture Imran Khan termed the release of Indian pilot as a “peace gesture”.

Earlier, India had called for the “immediate and safe return” of the Indian pilot and had termed the circulation of videos showing his “capture” by Pakistan as a violation of international law and in contravention of the Geneva Conventions.

Updates on the India-Pakistan stand-off

  • Amidst ongoing tensions between India and Pakistan all three defence services of the country, Indian Army, Indian Air Force and the Indian Navy will address a joint press conference today in New Delhi at 1700 hrs (5 pm IST). The spokesperson from the Ministry of External Affairs will also join this conference.
  • This joint press conference is expected to give clarity on the Indian Air Force pilot that has been taken as a prisoner of war (POW) by Pakistan. The IAF pilot was involved in a dogfight with Pakistani F-16 when it had intruded Indian airspace on Wednesday morning. The IAF pilot shot down Pakistan’s F-16 before his plane was hit. He had to eject and landed in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir and had since been in Pak Army’s custody.
  • Indian Prime minister Narendra Modi will chair a meeting of the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) later in the evening today, which will be followed by Union Cabinet meeting at his residence.
  • Pakistan has expressed its unhappiness over India’s invitation to attend the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). It is yet not clear if Pak’s foreign minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi will attend the OIC meeting after he threatened to boycott the meet over invitation to External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj.
  • Pakistan’s Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi has put a condition to return Indian Air Force (IAF) pilot— Wing Commander Abhinandan only if India helps ease the conflict. “We are willing to return the captured Indian pilot if it leads to de-escalation,” he was quoted as saying. He also said the Saudi foreign minister was expected to visit Pakistan with a special message from Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman, who visited both Pakistan and India earlier this month.
  • Sources within Indian government have said that India has not asked for any consular access to Abhinandan. “The IAF pilot has to be repatriated unconditionally and immediately, there is no question of any deal,” the Press Trust of India said.
  • United States President Donald Trump said earlier today that there would be some “reasonably decent news” on the conflict between India and Pakistan. “They have been going at it and we have been involved in trying to have them stop,” Trump said. “We have been in the middle trying to help them both out.”
  • Meanwhile, Pakistan has shut its airspace, forcing all commercial airlines to re-plan their aerial routes. Thai Airways International said that it has cancelled all flights to Pakistan and Europe that has left thousands of passengers stranded in Bangkok.

What Geneva Convention says about PoW?

As per the reports coming from Pakistan army, Indian Air Force’s Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman, in Pakistani custody after his plane was shot down on Wednesday, will be governed under the Geneva Convention of 1929. During the Kargil War, Flight Lieutenant Kambampati Nachiketa was captured after his MiG-27 suffered a flameout while destroying enemy positions in the Batalik subsector. He was captured by Pakistan on May 27, 1999 and remained in Pakistani custody for more than a week. He was repatriated to India on June 3 of that year, as per Geneva Convention.

Here’s what you should know about Geneva Convention:

The Geneva Conventions comprise four treaties, and three additional protocols, that establish the standards of international law for humanitarian treatment in war. The term ‘Geneva Convention’ usually denotes the agreements of 1949, negotiated in the aftermath of the Second World War (1939–45). The Geneva Conventions extensively defined the basic rights of wartime prisoners (civilians and military personnel), established protections for the wounded and sick, and established protections for the civilians in and around a war-zone. It asserted that PoWs be given humane treatment and adequate feeding, forbidding the belligerents to apply undue pressure on prisoners to supply more than a minimum of information. In 1977, the protocol to cover both civilians and combatants in the conventions was approved with the help of negotiations from the Red Cross.

The convention has the following aims:

1. Immunity from capture and destruction of all establishments for the treatment of wounded and sick soldiers and their personnel,

2. Impartial reception and treatment of all combatants,

3. Protection of civilians providing aid to the wounded, and

4. Recognition of the Red Cross symbol as a means of identifying persons and equipment covered by the agreement.

Current scenario and Geneva Convention:

If Wing Commander Abhinandan is officially declared as a PoW, then in accordance with Article 118, first paragraph, of the 1949 third Geneva Convention, “Prisoners of war shall be released and repatriated without delay after the cessation of active hostilities” and “unjustifiable delay in the repatriation of prisoners of war or civilians” is a grave breach of the Protocol.