Home Blog Page 323

“A Savage Logic” – Albert Einstein on Anti-Semitism

The power of resistance which has enabled the Jewish people to survive for thousands of years has been based to a large extent on traditions of mutual helpfulness. In these years of affliction our readiness to help one another is being put to an especially severe test – Albert Einstein before the outbreak of WWII

Anti-Semitism has played a brutal role in human history. It continues to play one. Its manifestations vary by country, culture, and time. Yet, it’s the flavour of bitterness on the proverbial tongue, hatred in the heart, and ignorance of the brain. A sensory echo through time.

It’s something of a majority poison, as exhibited in other ethnic hatreds. Where, with some rare few, it becomes a form of transcendent hatred of ‘the (despised) Other,’ as in that which is not understood and deemed condemned by God Almighty or the all-knowing State.

Whether secular statehood or religious injunction, anti-Semitism has shown its face for millennia. Even the great geniuses of history have been struck throughout their lives to the formulations of ethnic supremacy against them, Albert Einstein famously went through numerous tribulations due to this.

Adam Richter in “Einstein faced antisemitism in his early career” reports Einstein experienced anti-Semitism, even after the publication of his theories and the garnering of international fame. He states:

Einstein continued to face criticism that focused on his Jewish heritage, particularly in his native Germany. Nazis and their sympathizers decried his “Jewish science,” with its unusual ideas about the relativity of space and time, which they believed undermined the more credible “Aryan science.” After class, a student approached me and asked a question that surprised me: Where did all this prejudice against Jews “suddenly” come from in the 1920s and 1930s? Why would the Jews be singled out in the scientific community? I ended up explaining to the student at length that the growth of antisemitism [sic] in Europe was anything but sudden. Rather, its roots extended back as least as far as the Middle Ages, when Jews were expelled from numerous European cities and regions.

Einstein was issued criticism, not for his ideas or his political stances but, his heritage, Jewish ancestry. That which he could not change and remained stuck with as an adult, as an old man, as a legacy, and as an internationally famous genius. That’s part of the poison of anti-Semitism.

Also, it reflects the common trend for century after century of hatred towards an individual because of their ethnicity, as a Jewish man, woman, or child, rather than in things in which they would have a choice. Misogyny, hatred of Arabs, anti-Asian sentiment, derision and exclusion of personhood status of black people, remain much the same.

A deep and abiding hatred of an individual for that which Nature, Necessity, God, or their parents bestowed upon them. It can become as ridiculous, unnecessary, and cruel, as a criticism of “Jewish science” as if scientific or empirical facts and mathematical principles cared about the ethnicity of the person who discovered them or posited them.

All ethnic hatreds stem from the worst of human nature and an ignorance of human nature, simultaneously. The idea of the “Jewish science” was seen, to anti-Semites, as a corruption if not an anti-thesis of “Aryan science.”

At core, a split between German Gentiles and German Jews set forth by German Gentiles, as the dominant ethnic grouping, against the minority, German Jews, though with an internationalist tinge because of its focus on the anti-Jewish sentiment as the center of the storm.

“Jewish science” and “German science,” as such, simply or merely reflect the prejudices and the ignorance of individuals about science or about human nature; where, science, as a manifestation of a plural process grounded in human experience and sense-enhancing tools, represents a universal attempt at acquisition of the true approximations of Nature’s principles and form.

Anything less than this can be considered both an affront to one’s God, oneself, or Nature, as in honest and sincere work for truth rejects parochial labels of its proper process, science, as German science, Jewish science, even Canadian science.

Canadians, Jewish peoples, and Germans do science, practice it in other words, but they do not produce Canadian science, Jewish science, or German science, as in ethnic-based truth because of an ethnicity; only the products of reality found through science as a process of sincere searching for truth – even the fleeting.

In a matter of fact, these remain, as Einstein noted, harbingers of hatred, and death, spanning a far time into the past, even to the Middle Ages “when Jews were expelled from numerous European cities and regions.”

Some make the claim of this spanning back to the foundation of Christianity with the claim of Jewish peoples, as a whole, murdering the Son of God, so the justifications for hatred and violence continue into the present theologically too.

It was not merely the Germans. Americans, too, exhibited this formulation of hatred. In “Albert Einstein’s letter denouncing antisemitism in US academia on sale,” Rossella Tercatin quoted Einstein, who said:

The hostile attitude of universities towards Jewish teaching staff and students has been increasing perilously, even though it manifests in a hypocritical manner…

Unfortunately, the current Jewish leaders do not comprehend the seriousness of the situation, similar to the German Jews in the time before Hitler. They believe that they are able to put an end to the problem by being silent and disregarding it, and they thus miss the time for creating places of support…

This is not just true for the functions of the educational system, of course, but in economic and social terms as well…

Between World War I and World War II, there were quotas in American universities, or institutions of purported higher learning, on Jewish students.

When you read Einstein’s Pacifism and World War I By Virginia Iris Holmes, she talks about how even when offered an executive board position of the Association for Combating Antisemitism (Verein zur Abwehr des Antisemitismus) in September 1920; his step-daughter and secretary, Ilse Einstein, wrote:

Prof. Einstein instructed me to inform you that in his opinion we Jews cannot contribute to combating antisemitism [sic] through a direct campaign. Since your view on this point differs from that of Prof. Einstein, I respectfully request in his name that you kindly refrain from your plan – of electing Mr. Einstein onto the board of your association.

Einstein expanded on the letter in Israelitisches Wochenblatt ten days after the rejection of the effort in terms of the direct combat of anti-Semitism. Einstein “expressed his support for the socially underprivileged East European Jews and showed a leaning toward cultural Zionism and the cultivation of pride in a positive Jewish identity.”

Stuart Clark in “Why Einstein never received a Nobel prize for relativity” argued for the role of anti-Semitism in the lack of an eventual Nobel Prize for Einstein based on Relativity (Special Relativity and/or General Relativity), even with a “decade’s worth of Nobel nominations behind him.”

The reasoning: “Antisemitism [sic] was on the rise in Germany; Jews were being scapegoated for the country’s defeat in the war. As both Jew and pacifist, Einstein was an obvious target. The complexity of relativity did not help either. Opponents such as Ernst Gehrcke and Philipp Lenard found it easy to cast doubt upon its labyrinthine mathematics.”

In 1921, nonetheless, Einstein was awarded a Nobel Prize. However, the threats of harm to self, whether livelihood or life, can make an individual weary. When based on ethnic grounds, or ethnic hatred roots, this becomes no different for these individuals.

Anti-Semitism is a poison in the vein; it can be drained from the public consciousness through a consistent moral effort to tune into the natural conscience of most of humanity in the form of the humane rather than the heavy-handed, resource-wastage of the inculcation of the inhumane.

Otherwise, as Clark notes on the outcomes of hatred in mind, wrote, “German foreign minister Walther Rathenau had been murdered by anti-Semites. In the subsequent investigation, the police had found Einstein’s name on a list of targets.”

Physics remains about reading the signs of Necessity, as supreme, in Nature, including human nature. Einstein had insights here too. In “A decade before the Nazis came to power, Albert Einstein warned of the rise of anti-Semitism,” Natasha Frost described a letter written by Einstein to Maja (his sister) as a warning about the “grave dangers” (Frost) coming to them.

Rathenau was a close friend of the Einstein family. Hitler was a minor political figure known for targeting of Jews in speeches. Einstein began to frame himself as a “free man.” Someone without tenure and disconnected to the universities.

As Aron Heller describes in “Einstein warned about rise of antisemitism more than a decade before Nazis seized power, letter shows,” the Nazis immediately began instituting anti-Semitic legislation as soon as they came into power in Germany.

Frost stated, “In 1933, the Nazis passed laws prohibiting Jews from holding any official positions, including teaching at universities.”

He had joined a League of Nations Commission, where he saw himself becoming a sort of itinerant preacher. Maja, meanwhile, lived in Italy Fewer than 20 years later, Benito Mussolini instituted anti-Semitic laws. Fascists are anti-Semites, historical lesson.

These sentiments born of hard-won experience reflect the statement about a “savage logic” stated in a letter to Jawaharlal Nehru, Prime Minister of India, in 1947, where these sentiments mark a direct discourse on the victimization of Jewish peoples “for centuries” while “bereft of all the rights and protections which even the smallest people normally has…”

“Long before the emergence of Hitler I made the cause of Zionism mine because through it I saw a means of correcting a flagrant wrong… The Jewish people alone has for centuries been in the anomalous position of being victimized and hounded as a people, though bereft of all the rights and protections which even the smallest people normally has,” Einstein stated, in full, “Zionism offered the means of ending this discrimination… The advent of Hitler underscored with a savage logic all the disastrous implications contained in the abnormal situation in which Jews found themselves. Millions of Jews perished… because there was no spot on the globe where they could find sanctuary…The Jewish survivors demand the right to dwell amid brothers, on the ancient soil of their fathers.”

To discontinue this ornery state of affairs for more than two millennia, a new way forward means a new discourse about wider humanity in the presence and form of a life lived out in a humane manner with a civilized logic, not a “savage logic,” as exhibited in even the great societies of their time, in the arts, literature, philosophy, and science; as they went from a more civilized logic to an outright savage logic, the highest, of the time, can be brought to the lowest in the darkness of the inhumane apart from the light of the humane, thus chary vigilance in perpetuity becomes a virtuous necessity – a salve to the ill of “savage logic.”

Photo by Taton Moïse on Unsplash

Stigmata of the Enigmata – or, the Catholics, and Leonardo

Christian is a Philosopher that comes from Belgium. What identifies him the most and above all is simplicity, for everything is better with “vanilla ice cream.” Perhaps, for this reason, his intellectual passion is criticism and irony, in the sense of trying to reveal what “hides behind the mask,” and give birth to the true. For him, ignorance and knowledge never “cross paths.” What he likes the most in his leisure time, is to go for a walk with his wife.

Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Insofar as some reasonably substantive historical work displays the personality of Leonardo (Da Vinci), we can stipulate some probabilities about the man: gay or male homosexual, left-handed, vegetarian, wore purple and pink tunics, polymath, wrote in reverse to the norm of culture then and now, illegitimate child, no real last name, son of a notary father and peasant mother, an empiricist-logician without formal education or schooling, and some formal training in the arts under Andrea del Verrocchio, and, of course, without equal amongst contemporaries. Any thoughts on Leonardo Da Vinci? (Personally: an eminently lovable person.)

Dr. Christian Sorensen: Along with sustaining the eminence of Leonardo da Vinci, I think that it is necessary, to reaffirm its enigmatic and progressive personality, all of which stands out overwhelmingly, with respect to the generality of his time and of our days, nevertheless, not everything can be inclusive, if of what is talking about, is its homosexuality, which from my point of view, and contrary to what Freud argued, was not a repressed desire. Indeed, it was conscious enough, to have lived it, at the same level of his other desires, and then, unlike its other qualities, it would have followed the same fate, that the one is followed currently, in the sense of going unnoticed, which is what I believe that happens, to the vast majority of men, when they put into play, their masculinity, through what I will name as heterocuriosity, that strictly speaking, it is a camouflaged bisexuality, which I consider to be structurally constitutive, both physically and psychologically, therefore ultimately represents anyway, and no matter in what context it takes place, a facet of homosexuality. In this sense, for me, and from a metaphorical perspective, Da Vinci’s kind of homosexual latency, becomes by analogy, not in what most believe as genial creativity, but in what for me has to do with a creative genius, that expresses in itself, by showing and hiding at the same time, as if it was a divinity, what I think it’s his writing with crooked lines. Due to the above, I believe that Da Vinci, was the first to have the intention, of creating an underlying mystery, foundable within the expressed message of its work, and containing as such, what I will denominate as achieved significance of the word, which is going to be related, in turn, with something external to the work itself, while the external to which it refers, will also be implicitly present in it. The aforementioned, suggests also, the fact of discovering, that his main value, from my point of view, is a sort of game of interactions, that’s being displayed between the symbol and their hidden meanings, which lastly enables to conclude, that there’s an inexhaustibility, that places Da Vinci and his work, in something equivalent to what would be the place of the universe, where the only findable limit, is the reason.

Jacobsen: Da Vinci commonly repeated himself. Prismatic lessons in orbit around the same orb. For example, compare the three quotations here:

  • These scholars strut around in a pompous way, without any thoughts of their own, equipped only with the thoughts of others, and they want to stop me from having my own thoughts. And if they despise me for being an inventor, then how much more should they be despised for not being inventors, but followers and reciters of the works of others.
  • Although I cannot quote from authors in the same way they do, I shall rely on a much worthier thing, actual experience, which is the only thing that could ever have properly guided the men that they learn from.
  • I am well aware that because I did not study the ancients, some foolish men will accuse me of being uneducated. They will say that because I did not learn from their schoolbooks, I am unqualified to express an opinion. But I would reply that my conclusions are drawn from firsthand experience, unlike the scholars who only believe what they read in books written by others.

He would make a poor academic. For the formally uneducated with unmeasurable talents, what seems like the sensibility to less capable others with prestige, title, and connections for Da Vinci?

Sorensen: I think that it causes nausea, since the nothingness of being is fully revealed, as an act of fatuous sincerity, that is to say, nothing is not present, as negation, in the sense of absence, as occurs with the immeasurable ignorance, but instead, what happens is equivalent to a doctoral ignorance, where an absent presence is produced, since something present, presents itself as such, at the same time, that it becomes an absence, by double negation, because what is shown as evidence, is actually being hidden, and therefore, it’s not presented, meanwhile on the other hand, what seems like evidence, is not perceived as such.

Jacobsen: Any favourite quotations properly attributed to Da Vinci?

Sorensen: Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.

Jacobsen: What seems like the true philosophical stance of Da Vinci on God, the Bible, religion, theology, the sciences, Christianity, and nature, reality Itself?

Sorensen: The fact that precisely, reality in itself, is the only true thing, since from his point of view, all knowledge, should be born from experience, and from the perception of the senses, therefore, if any reality is not empirical, then it shouldn’t be assumed as existent, and in consequence, no knowledge, that doesn’t have its origin in the latter, can be either accepted as truth. Not for nothing, Da Vinci says, that when he meets God, he will claim him, for all the faults that exist within the world, which in my opinion means then, that God could not have created nothing, since then something, would not work correctly, between God and its perfection, in consequent its entity neither does exist, nor would there be any conversation between both. In more tangible terms, I think that just as Da Vinci despised metaphysics, due to its unmeaningful etherealness, in the same way, he also felt an allergy with theology, that was further projected towards the clergy, by denouncing them as corrupts, and by calling to disobey their authority, through its works.

Jacobsen: Any thoughts on the Catholic funeral for Da Vinci?

Sorensen: Regarding Da Vinci’s funeral in itself, I can only say, that many myths have been woven, and that there are more uncertainties than assurances about it, however, especially around his death, and in relation to its testament, left to the notary of Amboise, draws the attention, the fact that Da Vinci, had requested, three solemn Masses, with deacon and sub-deacon, and thirty Gregorian Masses, without chorus. Regarding its desire, plenty of things may be said, though from my perspective, what actually is emphasized, is the symbolic meaning of number three, that for me means knowledge, in the Hebrew sense of the word emet as truth, which signifies without death, and that as such, was repeated three times. Therefore, if the presence of the priest is taken into consideration, then I will propose as an interpretation, the appearance of number thirty-three, which coincides in turn, with the age that Jesus had when he died, while the masses without singing, are related with what for me, is the metaphor of the holy Grail, and not, with what is the holy Grail in itself, since it belongs to the sacred enigma, of which its secret, along with having circulated between different depositaries, has been split into parts, that individually, do not say anything about themselves, except if they are completely assembled, which then, is going to imply a certain knowledge, that is not only hidden, but also, that’s lost in time, because it refers to a lineage, already assimilated, and therefore, untraceable.

Jacobsen: Regarding the (Roman) Catholics, what are the bases for their faith?

Sorensen: I think, that the faith of Roman Catholicism, is a faith without bases, since it refers to a reality, which is not real, at the same time, that it has always tried to erase the traces of all it, that is to say, of the reality that regards Jesus and Mary Magdalene. The last, has been in that way, from the medieval crusades, through the Renaissance and modern-day with the witch hunts, among which, I believe, that Leonardo Da Vinci was a victim, and until now, where the probable current murders, who are seeking to destroy, any evidence, related to the depositaries of the sacred enigma, by carrying out, from the darkness, and with the protection of their sacramental secrecy, silencing conspiracies, that hide behind organizations, such as the Opus Dei, since in that way, they continue maintaining a hierarchical, patriarchal and anti-egalitarian power structure, which ultimately, does nothing more, than to reaffirm their intolerance, and what I am going to name, as the supposed exclusivism of their Christian faith, that’s exactly the opposite, of what it is for me, the liberating egalitarianism of the feminine principle, represented by Maria Magadalena and by the primordial pagan goddesses, to whom this Jewish woman, would somehow be assimilated.

Jacobsen: What seem like the good, the neutral, and the bad of their faith?

Sorensen: I think, that the bad thing about their faith, is that it exists, meanwhile, the neutral issue, is that it is an empty faith, because as such, it says absolutely nothing, therefore, the good news about it, would be, that this and its Roman Catholic Church, may collapse and disappear promptly, since with doing so, for the first time, they would be making something for the commonwealth of humanity.

Jacobsen: What were some close social and professional entanglements with Opus Dei and the Vatican for you? What were the lessons from the experience?

Sorensen: I did my philosophy studies, at the Ponticia Università della Santa Croce in Rome, which is physically located in the Palazzo di Sant’Apollinare, since the 14th century, and which was in practice, the old College of Cardinals, where for example, the anti-Pope Benedict XIII, the Nazi Pope Pius XII, and the Pope of the Second Vatican Council, John XXIII, studied. While I was studying, the Opus Dei, offered me to do, a second doctorate in psychology in Germany, and they wanted me to work, in Spain and the United States, with two world-renowned psychiatrists, Aquilino Polaino and Alexander Lyford Pyke, respectively. Simultaneously with the last, they gave me the possibility, of accessing to a sort of secret library, with documents and texts that belonged to the Roman Catholic Church, since the 11th century, and which have been for hundreds of years, forbidden literature for everyone, other than a select group of ecclesiastical authorities, therefore I was the exception to this rule. Indeed, regarding these readings, I had to take an oath, in front of a commission of clergy, under penalty of excommunication, in case that I dared to disclose the content of them. My stay in Rome, allowed me to maintain a physical closeness and friendship, with both the Vatican and the Opus Dei, because in fact, I lived in via Aurelia 145, which was an exclusive condominium, for the diplomatic staff of several embassies, and was located meters from the perimeter wall of the Vatican, at the same time, that I also strengthened close ties, among others, with Joaquin Navarro Valls, who was the spokesman for twenty-two years, during the pontificate of John Paul II, and with Monsignor Mariano Fazio, who is the future successor, of the current prelate of the Opus Dei. In addition to the above, I had the opportunity, to get to know the Vatican banking, since its director of finance, Piero Bagio, to whom I arrived recommended by someone of the Opus Dei, was the person who opened my personal account, in the Ambrosian bank. If I had accepted, all the chances the Opus Dei gave me, with all certainty, I would have assured my existence, from a financial and professional point of view, nevertheless as a counterpart, I would have had to be satisfied, with the will of flying like a poultry, which in concrete would have meant, to sell my soul and spirit, in exchange for wealthness, question to which, I actually was not and I am not willing to do. On the other hand, I wanted to have a training in metaphysics, and from that point of view, I think that the most optimal way to do it, was in a pontifical university with ecclesiastical orientation, that as well, is found in the crib of the Roman Catholic Church, therefore, this was for me, the most suitable place for achieving the goal, not only for all the aforementioned, but also because I think, that the best place, where a bird can take refuge, so as not to be spotted by a hawk, is by hiding under his wings.

Jacobsen: Why is Roman Catholicism one of the most dominant faith sects in the world now?

Sorensen: Because it is the only religious sect, that delivers certainties. All other religions and sects, propose the existence of a sort of silver cord, between God and man, which would allow a communication without intermediaries, though the counterpart, would be that this kind of bond, implies the fact of not knowing or to not recognize the will of God, and therefore, to be unaware, of if the soul, is worthy of enjoying the eternal beatitudes, regarding which, this sect would be its guardian executor, since represents, God on earth, and feels with the empowerment, to redeem sins, what from an underlying point of view, demonstrates, the reason of why this faith, is based on what I will denominate as double self-referentiality, due to the fact, that everything turns, in first person, around them, regardless of whether they are clergy or not. In consequence, generally, they are sort of insatiable black holes, that are waiting to be filled, with goodness, by God. Their neighbors, instead, only exists as scarlet covered steps, waiting to be trampled, for ascending towards heaven. Therefore, in my opinion, the Roman Catholic Church, is a sect, that by excellence, exalts the disordered desire for oneself, and occupies it, like a hook, for a huge majority, at the same time that exhibits, what for me is their facilitist attribute, since together with lacking any intellectual exigency, because almost all of their beliefs and precepts, are empty of any rational basis, and the few of them, which are considered by the clergy, as preambles of faith, because they would have some degree of explicability, actually what they follow, are tautological forms of reasoning, that lead them to chase their tails, just like a perturbated dog does with his. Obviously then, it is not surprising, that they make montages of realities, loaded with magical thoughts, which undoubtedly and for sure, may reach the heart of more than someone, especially if they are supported, by images full of luminous rays, that show languishing faces with blank stares. Deep down, nevertheless, they lack the most important, which is the history, a coherent story, able to account phenomenologically, of the existence of a subject within it.

Jacobsen: What was the work of the Roman Catholics in regards to fighting against anti-Semitism and fighting to further entrench and participate in anti-Semitism?

Sorensen: I think that both, are two sides of the same coin, which is the same strategy, currently followed, with their declarations of love, towards homosexual unions. Historically speaking, the Roman Catholic Church, has always been cynically anti-Semitic, since for them there is a historical crime and sin, due to the crucifixion of Jesus, with respect to which, the Jewish people is guilty, and therefore, would have to pay eternally, with the pain that rejection produces, and with the deaths, that the persecutions entail, nevertheless is in turn, another justification for punishing them, because they didn’t recognize, in the person of Jesus, the figure of the Messiah. In the same manner, according to their bizarre way of thinking, Jews would still cling to a doctrinal error, that they proudly defend, through their over-intellectualizations of the sacred scriptures, and consequently, by contributing, to maintain the world plunged into darkness, for not reaching the true faith. The aforementioned, suggests, that Jews should be silently fought, as enemies of the faith in Jesus Christ, however they forget, that the above is a kind of guiltness, that the lame man attributes to the pavement, because he is not able to walk through, since lastly what they’re preventing is that the Catholic world, gets to know the real true story, due to the fact, that this, would lead to the collapse of the Catholic Church. In conclusion, what they actually feel, is that they have no way to defend themselves, from the cornerstone that’s undermining the foundations of their feigned faith, therefore, the only thing left for them, is to use anti-Semitism as a threat for Jews, at the same time that they use Jews, as a threat for the rest of the world, nevertheless from my point of view, they lose sight, that the threat, is the weapon of who first feels threatened.

Jacobsen: What are the typical forms of argument of the Roman Catholics? What refutes to near certainty or in totality?

Sorensen: The Roman Catholic Church, sustains itself, through arguments, that have the form of apodypic certainties, which means, that they do not admit, any type of refutations, because the last would suppose, a discursive confrontation, which in turn, would give the option to reject a specific argument, and the last, does not happen with the apodictic reasoning, since it is equivalent to an absolute, that is imposed, by its querulous force, which is derived in parallel, from an authoritarianism, and not from a discursive force. Similarly, these kinds of arguments, take dichotomous forms, in order to polarize their meanings to the extreme, due to the fact, of being unable to integrate opposing elements, for forming afterwards, coherent wholes, and therefore, by the employment of a dualistic thinking, they tend to pigeonhole them, with rigid moral categories of good and evil, since they are incapable to resolve any cognitive dissonance, arising from apparent contradictory elements, due to the reason, that they’re incapable of accessing, towards what I will name as formal thinking. In consequence, they remain within a sensitive stage of thought, that at times, is only able of carrying out concrete operations, which never get to the complete abstraction of something.

Jacobsen: Thank you for the opportunity and your time, Dr. Sorensen.

Sorensen: You’re welcome, Mr. Jacobsen.

Photo by Mika Baumeister on Unsplash

Pakistan’s abduction of Baloch intellectual Dr Liaqat Sunni is ‘Naked Aggression’

Dr Liaqat Sunni, eminent Baloch intellectual and chairman of Brahui department at the University of Balochistan joined the list of people who have been disappeared by the Pakistani security forces. Strongly condemning the “enforced disappearance” of Dr Liaqat Sunni the Baloch National Movement (BNM) spokesperson said “naked aggression” against Baloch individuals continues as usual.

Dr. Liaqat Sunni is also a poet and writer who hails from Mastung in Pakistan-occupied Balochistan.

The BNM spokesperson explained that in accordance with a new strategy, Pakistan is trying to portray the abduction of Dr. Liaquat Sunni as a kidnapping for ransom so that the image of the state is not tarnished and the sentiments of Baloch nation can easily be diverted. “But the Baloch nation is fully aware of state barbarism in all its forms. The way, in which Dr. Liaquat Sunni was abducted in broad daylight by personnel who came in three vehicles, itself exhibits the tactics used by Pakistani agencies,” added the BNM spokesperson.

Pakistan’s abduction of Dr. Liaqat Sunni is yet another attempt to deprive the Baloch society of knowledgeable personalities and intellectuals. This policy has been going on for decades in order to inhibit the growth and development of Baloch nation in the field of science and literature. The assassination of Saba Dashtyari–the fountain knowledge, at Quetta by Pakistanis security forces is another example of their tactics. Hundreds and thousands of torchbearers of knowledge including Haji Razzaq, Ustad Ali Jan, Professor Razzaq and Zahid Askani had been earlier assassinated or disappeared. “But the struggle for freedom against slavery is continuous and will continue in the future. It is determined that the abduction of teachers, students, women and children will bring disgrace to Pakistan,” the BNM spokesperson added.

BNM further added that Pakistan was pursuing a multi-dimensional strategy of socio-economic aggression against the Baloch nation. “People are being killed and abducted in military operations across Balochistan on a daily basis. Houses and possessions are being looted and burned. Death Squads consisting of the Pakistani Army personnel, intelligence agencies and criminals have now morphed into bloodthirsty beasts. No one’s life is safe. The Baloch land has been turned into a hell for the Baloch people.”

“We are convinced that Dr Liaqat Sunni has been picked up by the secret agencies of the Pakistani state. The Pakistani state is trying to cover its war crimes by depicting such enforced disappearances as kidnappings. These kidnappings for ransom have been going on for the last several years in Balochistan. For instance, Pakistan Army’s Major Naveed demand six million rupees the release of Hafeezullah Baloch who was abducted from Dalbanden. This case came to light after the Pakistan Army chief had himself accepted that their Major had kidnapped Hafeezullah for ransom.”

In fact, Balochistan is a war zone. People are being abducted despite the presence of Pakistan Army outposts and camps that are present after every kilometer. This itself is an indication that the kidnappings across occupied Balochistan are being carried out with the consent and tacit support of the Pakistani state.

Guru Nanak Dev Ji gave a message of universal brotherhood

“Sadguru Shri Guru Nanak Pargateya Mitti Dhund jag chanan hoya”
(When Shri Guru Nanak came, mist went away and the world saw light)

This widely used exposition elucidates the journey of Guru Nanak Dev Ji in this world more than 550 years ago. His teachings have as much (if not more) relevance in today’s world’s as they had when he first expounded them to bring about a socio-religious change in a society tearing apart due to dogmatism and inherent contradictions.

The Guru was born in an affluent Hindu family on 29 November 1469 (according to the Nanakshahi calendar) at Rāi Bhoi Kī Talvaṇḍī (present day Nankana Sahib in Pakistan Punjab). His father Kalyan Chand Das Bedi aka Mehta Kalu was an affluent businessman of the area who had good relations with the local Muslim chieftain Rai Bhular Bhatti. His mother was Mata Tripta. Nanak had only one sibling, a sister named Nanki who was five years elder to him. She was the one person with whom he was particularly attached.

Nanak, as a child, remained immersed in his own thoughts and this behaviour caused considerable tension to his father who, quite naturally, wanted his only son to grow up as normal and take over his thriving business. Nanak, however, exhibited a rare intellect and insight into a religious philosophy that looked at a single supreme God (monotheist). He rejected certain teachings and rituals of both Hindus and Muslims.

Nanak's father had given him twenty rupees (a large sum at that time) and asked him to make a Sacha Sauda (profitable deal). Guru Nanak Dev Dev Ji bought food with the twenty rupees for ascetics as part of Sacha Sauda (profitable deal).
Nanak’s father gave him twenty rupees (a large sum at that time) and asked him to make a Sacha Sauda (profitable deal). Guru Nanak Dev Dev Ji bought food with those twenty rupees and fed sadhus and ascetics as part of Sacha Sauda (profitable deal).

In order to maintain a modicum of harmony between father and son, Bebe Nanki, on getting married, took her brother with her, to her husband’s house in Sultanpur Lodhi and it is here that Nanak spent his growing years. He worked as a manger in the provision store of the local chieftain, Nawab Daulat Khan Lodhi. While performing his duties well, he spent his spare time in meditation and in the company of ascetics. He also started building a Sangat (following) there.

On 24 September 1487, at the age of about 18 years, Nanak was married to Sulakhani, daughter of Mul Chand and Chando Rani, residents of Batala, Punjab. The wife of Guru Nanak DevJi is now called Mata Sulakhani. Nanak did go through a family life and had two sons named Sri Chand and Lakhmi Das, however, his inner core remained attracted to spirituality.

It is said that one day Nanak went for his early morning bath in the nearby river and did not return for three days. When people had given up on him as drowned he re-emerged and recited a divine message that is recorded in the Sikh religion as the “Mool Mantra,” as follows —

Ek Oaʼnkār
(One omnipresent God)
Saṯ Nām Karṯā Purakẖ Nirbẖa­o Nirvair
(Truth is God’s name; God is the doer; God is without fear; God is without enmity or hatred)
Akāl Mūraṯ Ajūnī Saibẖaʼn
(Timeless, undying; formless, beyond birth, self created self existent)
Gur Parsāḏ.
(By Guru’s Grace)

Guru Nanak Dev Ji then declared his life’s mission as one dedicated to the service of God and started his divine journey by advocating “Na Koi Hindu Na Musalman” (There is no Hindu, no Musalman). Thus, he set out his spiritual mission of considering mankind without shackles of caste and creed and religion, dedicated to the love of a single and supreme entity.

Guru Nanak Dev Ji went out on four long journeys across distant lands which are termed as Udasis. Even though there are no authenticated accounts of these spiritual journeys, their context becomes clear from the Bani that he quoted during his interaction with various peoples.

It is believed that the four corners of his travels stand at Mount Sumer (Mount Kailash) where he held his most significant discussion with the ascetic Baba Gorakhnath and his 84 Siddhas; then onto to Assam in the East, Mecca-Medina in the West and Sri Lanka in the South. In the context of modern India, his signature in the form of some historical monument of fables are to be found in Himachal Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Uttar Pradesh, Sikkim, Ladakh and even Nepal and Tibet and, of course, in Punjab. What is significant is the Gurdwara Pathar Sahib in Ladakh; the imprint of his sandals in Nepal and reference to “Nanak Lama” in Bhutan.

Guru Nanak Dev Ji wandered across many places in those days of limited transportation, possibly on foot with his faithful Bhai Mardana. It is said that Bhai Bala also accompanied him in his travels but this is refuted in some historical quarters. In every place he was known to sit outside the city, accept invitations from followers and devotees and confer with the poorest of the poor and Kings alike.

Guru Nanak Dev Ji, thus, delivered his message of the entire mankind being one under the spiritual umbrella of a single creator – “Manas Ki Jaat Sabhe Ekay Pehechani Bo” (Human Beings should be recognised as one) far and wide. He never took any pretension of divinity, instead, he looked upon himself as the most humble servant of the supreme being whose definition he had given in his divine inspiration of the Mool Mantra. He advocated the concept of meditation and praise of the creator while staying connected with the world, unlike the meditative seclusion followed by Siddhas and Sadhus.

It is through the debates during his Udasis that his Bani crystalised into a spiritual message that was later recorded in the Guru Granth Sahib by subsequent Gurus and his devout Sikh disciples. The recording is in the form of nearly 1000 hymns set in superb poetry capable of being rendered by divine classical music. His essential message was “Kirat Kar, Wand Chak, Naam Jap” (Work with honesty, share what you have and take the name of the creator).

Twenty years after crisscrossing the land Baba Nanak finally decided to settle in one place and spread his message. For this purpose he chose a piece of land astride River Ravi that had been donated to him by Dhuni Chand, an important Governor in Punjab. He named this as Kartarpur (place of God). The Guru took to the practice farming and was soon joined by his wife and other family members. Thus, Kartarpur became the first commune of the Sikh religion.

Gurudwara Darbar Sahib, Kartarpur. The Gurudwara is located in the Shakargarh Tehsil of Pakistan's Punjab province and is just a few kilometres from the India-Pakistan international border. It is highly revered by Sikhs across the world.
Gurudwara Darbar Sahib, Kartarpur. The Gurudwara is located in the Shakargarh Tehsil of Pakistan’s Punjab province and is just a few kilometre from the India-Pakistan international border. It is highly revered by Sikhs across the world.

Within his community Guru Nanak Dev Ji initiated the concept of Sangat and Pangat. Sangat means congregation of people and Pangat implies sitting in rows and eating Langar (community food) together. The mornings and evening were spent in the recitation of Gurbani (holy verses),Kirtan (spiritual Hymns) and finally partaking food together in the Langar.

Guru Nanak Dev Ji appointed his devout follower Bhai Lehna as his successor and gave him the name Angad, denoting that he was a part of the Guru himself. Guru Nanak Dev Ji left his physical form on 22 September 1539 in Kartarpur, at the age of 70.

Making a Buck as a Mountebank – Astrologers, Mediums, and Psychics

1

British Columbia has a highly educated population. However, it doesn’t prevent the delusions of old and New Age filter into the communities and professions.

Freethought for the Small Towns: A Case Study“[1] gives a decent idea of this on a wide smattering of issues, including naturopathy and naturopaths who, by definition, claim medical doctor or doctor status while not being doctors in the local town here.

It’s province-wide, though. They’re fraudulent and found throughout the province. Astrologers, mediums, numerologists, and psychics, are much the same: frauds, or mountebanks, who make a living off lies.

Those who feed on the pain and/or gullibility of others, who have been termed “Psychic Vampires,” as in the cases of mediums who claim to speak to the dead of living loved ones. These are bad people claiming to know the outcomes and to speak for the dead of those who are alive and love them.

One of the most prominent self-proclaimed supernaturalists, self-claimed ‘astrologer,’ in British Columbia is Georgia Nicols. Someone who has chosen a profession based on a lie, while garnering some prominence within the Lower Mainland. In Langley, British Columbia, we have ‘psychics’ Linnea Pearson, Carole Serene, Courtney Dawson, and Christine Marie.

What is a psychic, though? Good question, RationalWiki states, “A psychic is a person purporting to have some sort of supernatural or paranormal ability to receive or interpret information in a way that normal people cannot and that empirical evidence cannot detect,” with claimed abilities ranging as follows:

If they wish to put them to a test, then the James Randi Educational Foundation has the right test for them with a $1,000,000 (USD) price tag attached to it. If they were serious, they would, as others, put up the gumption for the test to win some serious cash, or simply give up the act.

Powers affect the natural world, so can be tested under proper conditions if truly believed. If not, what exactly is the purpose of practicing it? It’s quite clear in the latter case, fraud; it’s also clear in the former, delusion or misunderstanding of the basics of how the world works to a modern person.

These people are professional frauds because psychic powers do not exist, as in they are ‘psychic powers.’ I know the economy has gone through a dip of sorts, but I find this absurd play-acting of the fantastical idiotic.

In the wider area, there’s Psychic Jade, the Golden Spirit Centre of Excellence (Maple Ridge), the Mystic Eye Tarot, Psychic Visions 152, Psychic Readings by Sister Fatima, Tamara Hawk, the Yogi’s One Stop Psychic Shop, Sara Psychic Reader, Sasha Psychic Reader Fortune Teller, Raphael The World’s Medium, Parice Dawn, Salma Kassam, Linnea Psychic Medium & Spiritual Counsellor, Juan the Psychic (one of the few men), Kelly Chapman, and VS Spiritualist.

It attracts the worst gullibility in people, and so the worst traits reflected in the people who practice it. These aren’t good people; these people practice a charlatan’s art. If they believe their own nonsense, they’re delusional mountebanks, so stupid as well as vice-ridden.

Still the list continues, alas: Christine Marie, Psychic Amari, Acharya Rajesh, Indian Astrologer in Vancouver – Black Magic Specialist, 3rd Eye Designs & Visions, Bianca Psychic Reader, The Tarot Room, Andrea Zonnis, Psychic Reader Kathleen, ‘World Famous Indian Astrologer and Psychic’ (so “World Famous” as to not have a name or a review), Grayce and Gratitude – Psychic Medium, even the Paisley Town Psychic Fairs and Events.

The award for most grandiose and strangely amorphous title goes to… “Messages from a Star Traveler: Reiki, Energy Healing in North America, Psychic Readings, Past Life Regression, Soul Retrieval.” And don’t you forget it.

The buzzards line-up continues: “The Psychic Dr,” Maria Melo, Astrologer Nakulas, Psychic Readings-Astrology and Spiritual Healing, “Astrologer & psychic reader, Black Magic Removal, Love Spell, psychic” earned a rather amusing review, “The staff are very friendly [sic] and knowledgeable.” What, exactly, are these individuals knowledgeable about, now?

On and on, it goes: Courtney Carnrite, Cassandra McLeane, Dragonfly Essence, Chantelle Danielle, Sri Hanuman, Linda Pynaker, The Balanced Soul, Psychic Revelations, Psychick Healing Studio (clever title, actually), Soul Ascendency Psychic, Madame M. Live Psychics, Zljka Bosnjak Melody Rose Psychic, Cheri22, Siri The Intuitive… at this point, they’re MCs and DJs from the 80s, with far less talent.

One can feel hopeless in the mire of misanthropy exhibited in the cynicism of those who know they practice a charlatan’s art for a living. Other names include Lady of the Mists, Norma Cowie, Zais Heather, Skull Farm, Psychic Readings by Kristen – In the presence of Angels, Vanessa Corazon, Sacred Shamanism, Maureen Freeman, Hotno, Beyond Belief Psychic Entertainment, Gastown Psychic, Psychic Mama Sita, Kim Pellerin, Natasha Rosewood, Charmaine Accurate Psychic (I beg to differ), Cheryl Cole, Lynda Jane, Sukira Healing, Nipun Joshia (nShivoham), Ruth Hart, Cranbrook Clairvoyant, “Anne Clear Le Bihan,” and more.

The more I see, the more I see the pervasive ignorance and/or desperation for answers in an educational system not providing adequate answers; a culture discouraging questioning of the standard answers given in the society, as well as the mountebanks flourishing without many other skills as they have resorted to the lowest arts, charlatanry.

The only true creativity is that manifested in their names and company titles, while their names and company title aren’t that good. The names proliferate and simply become part of the fabric of the ignorance of the provincial culture in one of its many manifest ways.

The collection continued, consisting of Addi Strasser, Tarot Readings by Tegan, Signature Readings with a Twist, Oracle Emporium, Diane Daniels, T&T Spiritual & Wellness Connections, Indigo Awakenings, Speak for Me, Tarot & Psychic Reading Hotline Kelowna, Anna Babchuk, Grateful Medium, Conscious Quantum Energy Healing Services, Gypsy Moon, Spiritualist Alliance, Pivotal Hypnotherapy, Melissa Frisby, School of Intuition, Amethyst Books & Essence, Westcoast Reiki Centre, The Universal Brotherhood Spiritualist Church, West Coast Institute of Mystic Arts, Danielle Blackwood (the astrologer part), Kimberly Leslie, Airisa, The Oracle at Whistler, and Oracle at Sechelt.

In short, there’s a huge number of individuals practicing a mountebanks profession, making something of a living, while somewhere between believing their lies or knowingly lying to the public, for a buck.

A critical culture could more directly pummel this phenomenon of fraudulence with examples given in the aforementioned, whether primarily in psychics, but also astrologers, mediums, numerologists, Reiki practitioners, and the like.

[1] “Freethought for the Small Towns: A Case Study,” (2020), in part, states:

…Another issue practice is reflexology, as seen in Health Roots & Reflexology [Ed. Lisa Kako, Alison Legge.]. Quackwatch concludes, “Reflexology is based on an absurd theory and has not been demonstrated to influence the course of any illness… Claims that reflexology is effective for diagnosing or treating disease should be ignored…” …As Dr. Harriet Hall in “Modern Reflexology: Still As Bogus As Pre-Modern Reflexology“ said, “Reflexology is an alternative medicine system that claims to treat internal organs by pressing on designated spots on the feet and hands; there is no anatomical connection between those organs and those spots. Systematic reviews in 2009 and 2011 found no convincing evidence that reflexology is an effective treatment for any medical condition. Quackwatch and the NCAHF agree that reflexology is a form of massage that may help patients relax and feel better temporarily, but that has no other health benefits…”

…A larger concoction of bad science and medicine comes from the Integrated Health Clinic [Ed. Kaiden Maxwell, Gurdev Parmar, Karen Parmar, Michelle Willis, Karen McGee, Erik Boudreau, Adam Davison, Nicole Duffee, Erin Rurak, Alyssa Fruson, Alanna Rinas, Sarah Soles, Wayne Phimister, and Alfred Man. Many, not all, in part or in whole, trained in and practicing pseudosciences – pseudomedicine – found in acupuncture, naturopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, craniosacral therapy, the Bowen technique, and so on. One can integrate several pseudosciences to formulate a clinic for ‘medicine.’ However, all this amounts to an elaborate integration of pseudosciences, an integrated pseudoscience clinic, whether in a quaint fundamentalist religious community village or not.] devoted, largely, to naturopathy/naturopathic medicine (based on a large number of naturopaths on staff) and traditional Chinese medicine with manifestations in IV/chelation therapy, neural therapy, detox, hormone balancing & thermography, anthroposophical medicine, LRHT/hyperthermia, Bowen technique, among others. We’ll run through those first two, as the references to them are available in the resources, in the manner before. Scott Gavura in “Naturopathy vs. Science: Facts edition” stated:

Naturopaths claim that they practice based on scientific principles. Yet examinations of naturopathic literature, practices and statements suggest a more ambivalent attitude. NDhealthfacts.org neatly illustrates the problem with naturopathy itself: Open antagonism to science-based medicine, and the risk of harm from “integrating” these practices into the practice of medicine… Because good medicine isn’t based on invented facts and pre-scientific beliefs – it must be grounded in science. And naturopathy, despite the claims, is anything but scientific.

The Skeptic’s Dictionary stated:

Naturopathy is often, if not always, practiced in combination with other forms of “alternative” health practices... Claims that these and practices such as colonic irrigation or coffee enemas “detoxify” the body or enhance the immune system or promote “homeostasis,” “harmony,” “balance,” “vitality,” and the like are exaggerated and not backed up by sound research.

As Dr. David Gorski, as quoted in RationalWiki, stated, “Naturopathy is a cornucopia of almost every quackery you can think of. Be it homeopathytraditional Chinese medicineAyurvedic medicineapplied kinesiologyanthroposophical medicinereflexologycraniosacral therapy, Bowen Technique, and pretty much any other form of unscientific or prescientific medicine that you can imagine, it’s hard to think of a single form of pseudoscientific medicine and quackery that naturopathy doesn’t embrace or at least tolerate.” The Massachusetts Medical Society stated similar terms, “Naturopathic medical school is not a medical school in anything but the appropriation of the word medical. Naturopathy is not a branch of medicine…”

…Now, onto Traditional Chinese Medicine or TCM, or Chinese Medicine or CM, also coming out of the Integrated Health Clinic, RationalWiki notes some of the dangerous, if not disgusting to a North American and Western European palette, ingredients:

CM ingredients can range from common plants, such as dandelion, persimmon, and mint, to weird or even dangerous stuff. Some of the more revolting (from a Western standpoint) things found in TCM include genitals of various animals (including dogs, tigers, seals, oxen, goats, and deer), bear bile (commonly obtained by means of slow, inhumane extraction methods), and (genuine) snake oil… Urinefecesplacenta and other human-derived medicines were traditionally used but some may no longer be in use.

Some of the dangerous ingredients include lead, calomel (mercurous chloride), cinnabar (red mercuric sulfide), asbestos (including asbestiform actinolite, sometimes erroneously called aconite) realgar (arsenic), and birthwort (Aristolochia spp.). Bloodletting is also practiced. Bizarrely, lead oxide, cinnabar, and calomel are said to be good for detoxification. Lead oxide is also supposed to help with ringworms, skin rashes, rosacea, eczema, sores, ulcers, and intestinal parasites, cinnabar allegedly helps you live longer, and asbestos…

Dr. Arthur Grollman, a professor of pharmacological science and medicine at Stony Brook University in New York, in an article entitled “Chinese medicine gains WHO acceptance but it has many critics” is quoted, on the case of TCM or CM acceptance at the World Health Organization, saying, “It will confer legitimacy on unproven therapies and add considerably to the costs of health care… Widespread consumption of Chinese herbals of unknown efficacy and potential toxicity will jeopardize the health of unsuspecting consumers worldwide.”  On case after case, we can find individual practices or collections of practices of dubious effect if not ill-effect in the town.

Photo by Scott Rodgerson on Unsplash

The Omni-Infinite – or, Finite Inversion-Externalization

0

One of the least endearing characteristics of the gods comes in the form of the psycho-anthropology of the gods. Those beings in whom individuals reflect and whom the divine reflect the mortal; it’s a duality of mirrors beginning in the human psyche.

That which is the psychological in humanity becomes the anthropology of the divine. A sense of the personal in the non-personal, even, where the divine meets the mundane. Some of the most important individuals in this respect have been the thinkers who devote themselves to the study of human psychology.

While, others have been those who study the workings of the divine. Even others, they have given their lives to the ways of the history of the gods. Even others, they commit themselves to a diligent study of those without sense.

I recall a story of a man from India who was a polytheist and who considered Donald Trump worthy of worship to some degree. In this sense, we can sense the sense of nonsense. Its appeal to the merely flesh and meat.

The gods are not only something of falsity or untruth. Once one moves past those notions of the divine, to reduce them down to size to the mundane, we can look at the ideas of the gods as human productions, as they are; whether actualized prior to human imagination, all gods must be constructed by human ingenuity, regardless.

In that, to conceive of something from the Infinite Nothing or the Imaginarium upon which all creativity or system depends, one requires a mind to structure it into a coherence, all of a piece, in other words.

Once this all of a piece-ness is presented, then the gods are made whole for human comprehension, even the ideas of the incomprehensibility of the ways of many or some of the gods, these, too, attribute a human limitation as a valuation of the possibilities of the gods.

In a more direct way, as with the mounts of the deceased burping forth from the Imaginarium, the gods can be viewed without the fear. They do not require a sense of love projected outwards from them either.

Neither fear nor love come from the dead, far as I know; these senses of the divine as the imaginary helps clarification so much, as if a principle of simplicity to parse the known and the unknown in regards to the gods.

As Einstein remarked, “The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honourable, but still primitive, legends which are nevertheless pretty childish.”

He rejected not only the childishness of the Bible or the word God; its primitivity and established reflection of human weaknesses. He rejected even temporally derived notions of a final purposes to humanity, as in a rejection of the idea of teleology, stating, “I feel also not able to imagine some will or goal outside the human sphere,” while rejecting naïve realism too.

While a world out there must be taken in a serious manner, as the great theoretician rejected Kant’s idea of a rejection of objectivity of space as something ‘hardly to be taken seriously,’ a supporter of the Ethical Culture movement and a secular humanist.

Someone who said, “A Man’s ethical behaviour should be based effectually on Sympathy, Education and Social Ties; No religious basis is necessary. Man should indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear and punishment and hope of reward after death.”

Someone who may remark as Noam Chomsky who stated on the question of God: As with Thomas Paine, if there is a God, then He is a Devil. Strong notion from powerful intellects, individuals of great influence in the history of intellectual thought.

The ideas of the gods as reflections of human beings are not new, nor can they be new, as these reflect more of the common ideas of the gods from generation to generation, as a mirror to the prejudices and self-perception of the people of a society. A society collapsed for a variety of reasons, as most have ended.

Always heed the words of Aurelius, ‘soon you will have forgotten all things, and all things will forgotten you,’ everything is temporary in this view, as with the societies and their gods. The gods as a formulation not as the weaknesses of society, but, rather, as the strengths of humanity externalized.

That which we wish was more. To posit a weakness of humanity in this view, it is as if to buy the Imaginarium as the reality. ‘Tis not fair wanderer, it is more human attributes considered strength – intelligence, powers over nature, beauty, leadership, presence and influence – taken to the Nth degree. So it is with all gods; this can be seen with the large finites of those traits or those Nths of traits made infinite, as in the Abrahamic God.

What this more realistically reflects is a sense of a psychological lack to some degree while deemed a properly strong one individually, something admirable, it is depersonalized apart from the individual personality.

While taken out of this context of the individual personality, it becomes part of the properties ‘out there’ in some abstraction because of its depersonalization from the individual. Following this depersonalization of the individual qualities, they become properties. These are taken once more as out in the world rather than simply in the mind.

This in-mindedness of them makes them a sort of psychological quality made objective property in the world. This property, in the most limited forms, becomes an anthropomorphic formulation of the god concept in which the gods reflects more of the individual form and capacities of the human being, which is where the traditional idea of the anthropomorphism of the gods inserts itself into human history after the gods have been inserted into human history by humans themselves.

Ones with infinite or omni-infinite capacities are claimed as fundamentally non-anthropomorphic. However, they are the anthropomorphic in the most important sense. It is an anthropomorphism in which this process of self-objectification through the making of a psychological quality as an objective property becomes something taken to the Nth degree.

Where, for example, the idea of the good nature of a human being, the benevolence of a human person, becomes divinized in the omni-benevolence of God. We can see this play out in the spatiality of human beings with the omnipotence of God.

With the ability to know things, as a virtue, this becomes omniscience. One time after another, these finite strengths of the human species become projected and made infinite, where there can be incalculable multiples of these infinities in which the ultimate is the omni-infinite, that which identifies with, inheres in, and constructs reality at the most fundamental levels and projects itself through all that exists and can exist as potential.

This externalization of the property becomes something once more reversed in which the finite becomes infinite, as the finite properties, formerly qualities, become infinite properties of God Himself. Once more, this becomes psychology, though, as God is made into a personal god with a personal identity.

A divine person, so a transcendent psychology, you see the process. It is a manner of inversion-externalization, where the finite and singular comprised of divisible, though unified, qualities, becomes properties, as these enter the objective world, formulate a divine character, made infinite, and then personal.

As follows: Name a psychological lack, objectify it as a property, externalize it as “out there” in the universe, then make it infinite and personalize it once more, so as to make an omni-infinite personality based on human lack. It’s a process of inversion-externalization.

Because the internal is made external, finite made infinite, and personal psychology made ‘divine’ psychology. All the pantheons of limited gods would be a self-limiting formulation going through the same process.

The gods are of use as much as we are them, whether Indian Hinduism or Pakistani Islam, not at all. Each of them come as one and the same operation while with individual, cultural, and people group manifestations, claimed as the objective truth for ever and always.

It’s not that we are the gods now; it’s that the gods were never here, but the gods have been a useful fiction. The question remaining: How much more useful is the fantasy?

Photo by Marc-Olivier Jodoin on Unsplash

Pakistan frees Gilgit-Baltistan leader Baba Jan, but keeps a watchful eye

Friday, the 27th day of November, was quite special for Gilgit-Baltistan so much so that cheerful sloganeering and celebrations went on till early next morning. Almost after a decade, their beloved leader Baba Jan was set free from captivity by the Pakistan Army.

The release of Baba Jan and other political prisoners Iftikhar Karbalai, Aleem Khan and Shakoorullah Baig had come after arduous protests. Over the last few months, entire Gilgit-Baltistan especially the people in Hunza/Gojal Valley had been on streets demanding the release of Baba Jan. The sea of protesters included men, women, children and the elderly. People’s anger against authorities in the picturesque valley had reached a tipping point that had Pakistanis and the Chinese worried. Gilgit-Baltistan is the starting point of $64 billion CPEC (China-Pakistan Economic Corridor) and a widespread revolt in the region would mean CPEC had come to a cropper. And so the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) instructed Pakistan Army to release Baba Jan from prison.

The decision to release Baba Jan was taken sometime in October this year but it had to be delayed by another month and a half as Rawalpindi did not want Baba Jan to have any participation in Gilgit-Baltistan’s provincial elections. Rawalpindi’s fears were not unfounded. In 2015 Baba Jan had run for the Gilgit-Baltistan elections from inside the jail and despite massive rigging he had defeated the candidates propped up by Rawalpindi. Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan and Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa must have weighed in the effects of Baba Jan’s massive popularity, waited for the Gilgit-Baltistan elections to get over on November 15 and then released Baba Jan along with his comrades on the night of November 27.

Demonstration in Hunza Valley for the release of Baba Jan. (Photo: News Intervention)

Yet, this was nothing short of a miracle for the denizens of Hunza Valley. Baba Jan and his comrades were serving life sentence on charges of terrorism and there was little hope they would walk free. Yet bowing to massive demonstrations and protests the Pakistanis were forced to relent. This is the victory of people’s power. At least on the surface this seems so.

Rawalpindi’s calculation is that the elections in Gilgit-Baltistan are now over and Imran Khan’s political outfit has already won enough seats to form the provincial puppet government in the 23-seat Gilgit-Baltistan Assembly.

A closer look at the underlying facts reveal a clearer picture. Pakistanis have not acquitted Baba Jan of the terrorism charges, rather his charges have been suspended and he has simply been asked to walk out of jail to quell people’s anger. Police sources in Islamabad say that the released political prisoners can yet again be arrested at the whim of ISI or Pakistan Army.

Background of Baba Jan’s arrest

This matter dates back to January 2010, when a massive landslide hit the Hunza Valley in Gilgit-Baltistan that killed around twenty people and blocked a portion of the River Hunza. Due to this landslide a huge artificial lake was created that submerged several villages in Attabad. This landslide was the result of massive on-going construction activities under CPEC (China-Pakistan Economic Corridor) at the Karakoram Highway whereby explosions were carried out in the seismically sensitive mountains around Hunza/Gojal Valley that subsequently triggered the landslide.

As the explosions cracked up mountains and landslide debris gushed into Hunza Valley the water flow of River Hunza got blocked and inundated dozens of villages at Attabad, Ayeenabad and Sarat. The rapidly rising water submerged around 20 kilometre area and over hundred thousand villagers across the Hunza/Gojal Valley were suddenly left homeless and fending for themselves.

Landslide that created the artificial Attabad Lake which eventually submerged dozens of villages in the Hunza/Gojal Valley. (Photo: News Intervention)

Islamabad under direct instructions from Chinese masters in Beijing accorded top priority to restoring the road connectivity at the Karakoram Highway and turned a blind eye to the plea of villagers to be compensated for their homes and loss of livelihood. The water in artificially formed Attabad Lake kept rising steadily and several adjoining villages faced the threat of permanent submersion.

It was at this time when Baba Jan along with his comrades stepped in. Baba Jan became the voice of villagers across Hunza/Gojal Valley and launched massive demonstrations demanding compensation for the submerged villages and for those whose family members had died in the sudden landslide. Local administrators of Gilgit-Baltistan never bothered to offer any compensation to the thousands of villagers.

On August 11, 2011 the then chief minister of Gigit-Baltistan Syed Mehdi Shah was travelling through the reopened Karakoram Highway when the Attabad villagers under the leadership of Baba Jan blocked their cavalcade. Instead of listening to their plea the police opened fire at peaceful demonstrators and killed two people.

This news about police firing and subsequent deaths spread across Gilgit-Baltistan and protests started all across the region. People felt they were being unnecessarily targeted and their rightful compensation. CPEC was looked upon as the harbinger of death and Pakistani regime as the enabler for this spiteful project. The extent and expanse of riots across Gilgit-Baltistan had Beijing worried. These were starting years of CPEC and it was being marketed as game changer across the globe. Beijing wanted to iron out all protests in Gilgit-Baltistan.

Locals on a sit-in demonstration at Gilgit-Baltistan in August 2020. (Photo: News Intervention)

Pakistan also had to show to Chinese masters that it rules Gilgit-Baltistan with an iron hand. Baba Jan and his comrade Iftikhar Karbalai were promptly arrested and charges slapped under the Anti-Terrorism Act. Their bail pleas were rejected and Baba Jan along with his comrades were sentenced to seventy years in prison. Baba Jan was 35 in 2011, and a seventy year jail term meant he would not walk out of jails in his lifetime.

Unrest in Gilgit-Baltistan

Islamabad did incarcerate Baba Jan and his political associates but could not erase away his popularity from the collective psyche of people across Gilgit-Baltistan, especially in the Hunza/Gojal Valley. It was Baba Jan who had first demanded rightful compensation to the people of Gilgit-Baltistan in lieu of the “development activities” carried out under CPEC. Baba Jan’s popularity continued to soar.

It’s precisely due to this reason that when Pakistan declared Gilgit-Baltistan as its fifth province earlier this year in order to hasten the loot of natural resources under CPEC, there were massive protests in Hunza Valley for the release of Baba Jan, who had become the rallying point. Pakistanis knew their time was running out and keeping Baba Jan behind the bars would mean an open revolt in Gilgit-Baltistan that could even spill off to Muzaffarabad and other cities of POK (Pakistan-occupied Kashmir).

Baba Jan’s release was only a matter of time. Now Islamabad and Rawalpindi needed to time the release such that Baba Jan or his political associate Iftikhar Karbalai could not in any way affect the “elections” of Gilgit-Baltistan assembly. With due help from Pakistan Army, Imran Khan’s PTI (Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf) managed to ‘fix’ the November 15 elections in their favour. And after electoral processes were completed Baba Jan was released from jail on November 27.

However, mere suspension and not acquittal from the terrorism charges means Rawalpindi wants to keep a close eye on Baba Jan’s activities and could possibly detain him yet again.

The next few months will be crucial for Baba Jan and Iftikhar Karbalai as they walk the fine line of leading the people of Gilgit-Baltistan under the shadows of Rawalpindi. Probably, Attabad Lake could offer a start point. Pakistanis advertising Attabad Lake as a tourist spot is rubbing salt to the wounds of Hunza/Gojal Valley denizens who still see their villages and hamlets buried under the lake’s belly.

Dozens of Hunza Valley villages lie submerged in this picturesque Attabad Lake. (Photo: News Intervention)

Kashmir: What is the Gupkar lobby fighting for?

Gupkar lobby’s utterance is in effect the dirge for the demise of dynastic rule and power. The dynamics of history is that old order changes yielding place to new. This is as true about the Sheikh House as that of Maharaja Hari Singh. The history repeated itself after seventy-three years. Nations enjoy permanence but not the monarchs or their glamour.

Farooq Abdullah presumes he can undo this universal truth by a show of mobocracy to which the Kashmiris have a historical penchant. Who does not know that his popularity is an enigma?  It has come to him essentially from being the son of late Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah though most Kashmiris are strongly apathetic to a dynastic rule. Dispassionately speaking, his contribution to Kashmir history is only in one prominent field and that is a plethora of colourful whims and eccentricities, all bandaged in self-aggrandizement. Yet he rejoices when told he has a method in madness.

His ideology of no accession to Pakistan, bequeathed to him by his illustrious father is neither a whim nor an eccentricity. It does not mean either hate for Pakistan or love for India, none of these. He does not support the option of Kashmir for Pakistan because he knows very well how Pakistan would treat Kashmiris nothing more than hewers of wood and drawers of water. He has spent days in the UK living and interacting with Pakistanis and PoK Diaspora there. There are no takers of his bluff in Pakistan but in India, there is no dearth of them, and the Sheikh dynasty survived because its bluff worked with the Indians.

After grabbing power — offered on a platter in October 1947— the “doublespeak” became an obvious political culture and tactical idiom of National Conference leadership particularly Sheikh Abdullah and his lineal successors. Since in its early days, NC had gathered political momentum through mosques — now a copyright tradition of Kashmir politicos — and the Sheikh had assiduously fathomed the naivety of Congress leadership, the “doublespeak” became almost a political lethal weapon very deftly handled by the valley leadership for seven long decades. Valley political heavyweights, one and all, ensured that the bluff percolated down to the Kashmir feudalists, elites and the local bureaucratic segments, and finally to the unsuspecting plebeians. Interestingly, even other political groups pronouncedly differing with the NC in their ideological viewpoint also found this Goebelsian propaganda convenient and serviceable option to further their game plan.

The Congress in power at the Centre was complacent with the doublespeak of the valley leadership considering it a short cut to good riddance but oblivious of the fact that it was inadvertently allowing the strong nationalist predisposition in Jammu region become its casualty. Jammu is not still coming out of that trauma. The worst is that the BJP High Command is incapable of understanding the genesis of the political trauma of Jammuites.

As Kashmir polity was rife with the doublespeak, it revealed the duplicity of intentions and willful abandonment of conviction on the part of local leadership. The first and most disastrous outcome of this phenomenon was the widespread corruption in almost all facets of the polity. Slowly and steadily it began eating into its vitals. The civil society in general and the administrative superstructure, in particular, began believing that perpetuating a general loot of public exchequer and assets was its birthright because Kashmir “an Islamic territory was occupied by a non-Islamic power”. The loot of the state property raised by a non-Islamic ruling structure was permitted by faith as “mal-i-ghaneem” meaning enemy property lawful for general loot. Therefore whenever the ulema preached honesty they added the sentence that the property of the non-Islamic entity was lawful to be looted. What the Indian Enforcement Department today calls scams, embezzlement, misappropriation, money laundering, hawala, illegal transactions, narcotic trade etc. sounds strange and alien to the ears of Kashmir Valley leadership and the brainwashed public both. When the religion legitimizes it in the name of mal-i-ghaneem, what right has the ED to proceed in the matter?

Sheikh Abdullah, founder of the political outfit National Conference that has a presence in certain pockets of the Kashmir Valley. (File Photo)
Sheikh Abdullah, founder of the political outfit National Conference that has a presence in certain pockets of the Kashmir Valley. (File Photo)

Has the Gupkar Alliance the welfare and development of Kashmir its primary objective? The development of Jammu and Kashmir, a heterogeneous conglomerate of humanity, along democratic, secular and egalitarian lines has been neither understood nor practiced by the valley majority based statecraft. How could they understand it when the J&K Constitution never accepted any group as a minority? It never considered minority as the wielding device and cementing force of a balanced social order and unifying ingredient. The alliance, as stated, is a loud lament for the loss of power and hegemony of a couple of ruling houses or local satraps and their ignominious auxiliaries, one and all pursuing the solitary agenda of self-aggrandizement and nepotism.

When late Mufti Saeed formed the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), he publicly announced that one of the important programmes of the new party was to help Kashmir get rid of the dynastic rule because it was the negation of democracy. On this count, Mahbooba conducted her Jamaat-i-Islami proxied election campaign and won. But today she stands shoulder to shoulder with the leader who has roped in six or seven smaller groups to lend their support to him as the scion of the Sheikh ruling dynasty. Farooq’s one-time Finance Minister’s son has a case of ₹170 crore bank loan for setting up industries. Instead, he has purchased properties in the European and Gulf countries all at the expense of Kashmiri taxpayer.  Notwithstanding his history, this former Finance Minister is a close associate of Farooq in the Gupkar Alliance.

National Conference President Farooq Abdullah with his son and former Chief Minister of Jammu & Kashmir, Omar Abdullah. (Photo: PTI)
National Conference President Farooq Abdullah with his son and former Chief Minister of Jammu & Kashmir, Omar Abdullah. (Photo: PTI)

How far are the valley leaders concerned with the welfare of Kashmir is evidenced by the Roshni Act scandal through which more than two lakh kanals of state forest land has been granted to the politicians, bureaucrats, corporate houses, capitalists, and influential persons of one particular community at throw away price causing a loss of billions of rupees to the state exchequer? The Roshni Act has been declared null and void by the High Court. This scandal took place when Ghulam Nabi Azad of Congress was the chief minister in a coalition government with PDP and the conspiracy was allegedly hatched in collaboration with Farooq. Is the Roshni Act a developmental project for the millions of Kashmiri people or for the thick creamy layer of its society?

During its long stints in power, the NC has nothing to show by way of concrete development of Kashmir. They always stonewalled outside investment on the pretext of leaving space open for local entrepreneurs. What is the result? Look how these local entrepreneurs and their enterprises have been contributing to the alienation of the people and financially strengthening the creamy class of Kashmirian society. Why have not the administrative organs of the state been able to submit utilization certificates for enormous funds they received under various schemes over time? Where has that money gone? Why have most of the Centers’ development schemes been abandoned soon after these were inaugurated? What has happened to various central schemes generally called PM’s schemes for this and that?

Mehbooba Mufti, PDP leader and former Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir. (Photo: PTI)

Kashmir Valley political parties have throughout pursued only a one-track policy of blackmailing the Centre with falsehoods, canards and fabricated stories. The simple formula which the Kashmir Valley leadership adopted in the course of insurgency beginning 1989-90 is “Hindostan sandooq band karega to Pakistan se bandooq lenge, meaning if India closes coffers on us we will grab guns from Pakistan.

Prime Minister Modi has understood the bottom of Kashmir doublespeak. He has taken strong measures to contain blackmailing of Central government and agencies. The easy flow of billions of rupees has stopped and the pockets of doublespeak robbers are going dry. Accountability has been initiated and the skeletons are crumbling out of the cupboards of broad-day burglar one by one. Their deep involvement in monetary scams, in overt empathy for militancy, in providing backdoor entries to government jobs to kith and kin, in looting the state exchequer, in corrupting society and services and in spreading falsehood and canards against India, are among their contribution to the development of Kashmir.

Now they want Kashmir to return to the same old order so that their path to perfidy and scandals is thrown open. That, in short, is what the Gupkar Alliance is fighting for. They want people of the valley to remain confined to straight-jacketed orthodoxy allowing no liberal ideas to grow and flow within the society. Progress and development of Kashmir is a distant cry and what sustains the unholy alliance is anti-India proclivities at a time when even in Pakistan saner voices are asking Pakistani government to understand and appreciate the nation-building ideology pursued by Prime Minister Modi.

In the final analysis, what is the Gupkar lobby fighting against? Yes, it has a comprehensive agenda for their fight. Let us itemize it. They are fighting the Home Ministry AGAINST (a) giving statehood to five lakh Hindu and Sikh refugees of 1947 carnage in Muzaffarabad, Mirpur and Rajouri living a stateless life for last seven decades (b) Against giving PRC (Permanent Resident Certificate) to nearly 2 lakh Valmikis whose services were formally requisitioned by the State government from Punjab as safai karamcharis more than half a century ago. Against (c) authorities taking action for clandestine resettlement of nearly 90 thousand Rohingya Muslims in Samba and Jammu district along the sensitive International Border and LoC thereby shredding Article 370 and Special Status proviso to pieces. (It will be noted that these people were given ration cards, Aadhaar cards, bank passbooks, water and electricity connections and other facilities within weeks of their arrival thus giving a clear proof that the valley-dominated regimes wanted to bring about demographic change in Jammu); against (d) Loot of nearly 2 lakh kanals of government land through illegal Roshni Act gifted away to ex-ministers, legislators, political VIPs, top bureaucrats, top businessmen and other favourites at a throwaway price. Not a single kanal has gone to a poor homeless Kashmiri urban or rural citizen; against (e) Kashmiri girls to whom the statehood status is desired to be restored even if they marry a spouse outside Kashmir, not only they but their progeny as well; against (f) Return and rehabilitation of ethnically cleansed seven lakh Kashmiri Pandits back in their homeland after grabbing or vandalizing their immoveable and moveable properties; against (g ) Investments in industrial enterprises with the potential of generating large scale employment for the unemployed locals; against (h) breaking monopolies by valley-based corporate houses that abet and disseminate anti-national and communal propaganda; against (i) universalization, liberalization and emancipation of Islamic society and harnessing it to the age of scientific and reason; against (j) the historic effort of the secular-democratic India to empower its minorities (especially the Muslims) and EWS with their constitutional and other rights, and against (k) holding entire Muslim community of the valley a hostage to conservative and orthodox Islam of Turko-Pak-Indonesian triumvirate where all beliefs converge on radicalization and weaponization.

The NC leadership is now preparing to invite China to help them get rid of Indian secular democracy and return to 14 centuries-old tribal social order to tell the world they are pure Muslims. If China can help Farooq Abdullah restore him the Kashmir Sultanate based on his religious philosophy, we would politely suggest Farooq go to Yarkand, Kashghar, Khotan, and Urumchi etc. in his first leg in Xinjiang and visit the hundreds of concentration camps for the Uighur Sunni Muslims to know what type of religious freedom they are enjoying. Kashmiris have a long history of inviting foreigners to come and rule over them. Farooq is meticulously preserving the tradition laid down by Maulana Sarfi and his delegation way back in the closing days of the 16th century to the court of Akbar. Hopefully, after his Chinese camaraderie, he will impress upon Kashmiris of the valley to enjoy the love of Chinese rule.

If the Gupkarists had any love for Kashmir they would have strongly condemned the attack planned by Jaish-e Muhammad terrorist organization of Pakistan that was foiled by brave Indian soldiers in Nagrota only recently. Anybody lamenting for Kashmir would not remain silent on such perfidy by Pakistan. This exposes the subconscious mind meaning the doublespeak of the Gupkarists nursing nothing but ill intentions against the Indian State and the nation.

The decision of the Gupkar lobby of participating in the DDC (District Development Council), Urban Local Bodies and Panchayat elections is a healthy decision. After realizing the blunder of boycotting previous Panchayat and other elections and leaving the space free for BJP to walk over, the Gupkar conglomerate has corrected itself albeit after a grave tactical miscalculation of which BJP took the fullest benefit. Their decision to participate in DDC and other elections this time is indicative of the fragility of their stand against democratic institutions of the county and their decision of fighting the elections jointly on the basis of fair distribution of seats is a big indication of their serious apprehensions about their ability to make a dent in the BJP constituency in the valley. It is so because they know the old game of rigging elections will no more work under present dispensation and the voters will no more be intimidated. No fewer than 18 BJP activists in the valley, or the Panchs and Sarpanchs have been gunned down so far by the militants reported to be enjoying overt or covert patronage of the politicians. The lobbyist did not have the humanism of even expressing condolence on the killing of these victims. The consequences of wanton destruction of innocent lives will have its far-reaching impact on the forthcoming elections. Interestingly, the constituent groups are askance at the usual hegemony of NC demanding lion’s share rightly or wrongly. The fissures in the phony unity of the cavaliers are not far to seek.

However, notwithstanding their antecedents, the lobbyists have taken a right step now, which is in the interests for genuine democratic dispensation in the Union Territory and its masses. Nobody anywhere in the world takes notice of their tantrum of restitution of abrogated articles or restoration of special status. The two power thirsty dynastic standard-bearers are standing on seashore and watching with utmost despondence their ship lowering down in the deep vacuum of history. One thing they fully and unanimously understand is that both of their reclining cushions viz. Pakistan and Congress, are either in the process of collapsing or have virtually collapsed. The takers and givers of doublespeak are conspicuous by their foolhardiness. There is still a chance of rectifying their waywardness and taking the masses of people of Jammu and Kashmir out of the morass into which they have been led. It is for the masses of the people to choose the right path as they are standing on the crossroad of history.

POK resident Naveed Majeed was brutally murdered, he didn’t commit suicide

Naveed Majeed was a young man from Bagh district, an employee of the WAPDA (Pakistan Water & Power Development Authority) and was on duty at the Bagh Grade Station. Naveed had a good family life, participated in social activities and sports. On November 20, Naveed Majeed arrived on duty at the WAPDA office and within a few hours he was killed inside his office. After this heinous murder, Naveed’s body was taken to the hospital and postmortem was done. However, as soon as Naveed Majeed’s body reached hospital, his murder was described as suicide and people started talking about Naveed’s death as a suicide.

The dominance of a select few in our society is such that even hundred percent murder cases are conveniently turned into suicide. We call Naveed’s death as 100% murder because Naveed had a very happy family life who happily participated in social activities, he was a sports lover, he had no economic, social or family issues due to which he would have commit suicide.

Even earlier we had seen that Punjabis at WAPDA (Pakistan Water & Power Development Authority) had slaughtered a local employee from Nendrai Bagh a few years back. That murder was also dismissed with a report that the victim was mentally unbalanced and had committed suicide.

Everyone knows that the real reason for these murders is that the Punjabis do not tolerate a local citizen in WAPDA (Pakistan Water & Power Development Authority). These Punjabis come to our city, kill our citizen and then get a Punjabi to replace him. Naveed has also been killed on this same premise.

During the whole volleyball season since March, and in the Bes Bagla tournament a couple of days earlier, we were together. I knew Naveed from very close quarters. From economic affairs to the family affairs we shared everything with each other, we were unbridled companions in times of sorrow and joy.

On his way to the WAPDA office Naveed used to have his daily breakfast from a nearby shop. On the day of his murder also, he took the breakfast at this same place and later on bought a volleyball from a sports shop in Bagh. Naveed said that if there was a lockdown due to the Coronavirus pandemic he would pass his time by playing volleyball as he would have nothing else to do. An hour later he was murdered.

Naveed’s body remained in the hospital for about six hours after the murder. Autopsy was done on his dead body, but during this time neither the hospital’s MS (Medical Superintendent) came to the hospital nor the DC (District Commissioner) or the SP (Superintendent of Police) reached the hospital.

It’s surprising that a young citizen of Bagh who was also an employee of WAPDA (Pakistan Water & Power Development Authority) was murdered and yet the Bagh administration along with the hospital’s administration remained completely negligent as if a sheep or goat had died, rather than a human being. Since beginning the police started talking that this was a suicide, an attitude of removing the burden from their head.

We could get Naveed’s body after protests by his family, but we were dismayed by the attitude of the administration regarding Naveed’s murder. We will protest at every possible place if the administration will try to prove that Naveed Majeed committed suicide or if the investigation is not done properly.

Naveed is dead and our collective attitude towards Naveed’s murder has become such that we will bury Naveed, saying that this was Allah’s will and may Allah grant him a high position in heaven. If we do not pressurize the police to investigate the real reasons in Naveed’s death then one day the police will report that this was a suicide.

Earlier also an employee of Nindrai was killed, then last year Hamza Imtiaz and today Naveed has been murdered. If our collective attitude remains the same then we must remember that none of our youth will be safe. Our young people will continue to become victims of the mercenaries and we will continue to bury them and pray.

We urge the administration, DC, SP and the SHO Bagh to put in public domain the FIR and preliminary medical report of Naveed murder case. All the WAPDA employees on duty with Naveed, including the in-charge, should be arrested immediately and brought under investigation, otherwise the youth will protest.

Violent attack on Kashmiri protesters at Rawalakot, POK

Rawalakot/POK: Acting on instructions issued by Islamabad the local administration baton-charged and used tear gas shells on Kashmiri protesters at Rawalakot in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (POK) on Wednesday. The protesters were demanding that the administration complete Tuli Pir Road in POK.

“Police used tear gas and lathi charged all the participants of the Public Action Committee at Chandni Chowk in Rawalakot, POK. Several people were injured in this mindless attack on peaceful protesters,” a local eyewitness from Rawalakot told News Intervention.

However, despite using tear gas shells and lathi charging the Rawalakot police have failed to disperse the protesters who have now reached in front of the commissioner’s office for a sit-in. Local sources said that the protesters are now sitting in front of the commissioner’s office.

A Kashmiri protester injured in police violence at Rawalakot, POK. (Photo: News Intervention)

Earlier, a large number of protesters had gathered in caravans at the Jabota Cross in heavy rain and cold, from where they marched towards Rawalakot in the form of a rally. It was then that Islamabad issued directions to its puppet administration in Rawalakot to use brute force and stop this protest march. The Chandni Chowk Police then baton-charged the protesting crowd and used tear gas shells. However, despite the police brutality, the protesters managed to reach the commissioner’s office and the protests were still on till the time of writing this news report.

Local Kashmiris continue with their protests in Rawalakot, POK. (Photo: News Intervention)

Rawalakot is a POK-based town, which Pakistan calls as Azad Kashmir (free Kashmir) but then local Kashmiris have absolutely zero rights. The local administration in Muzaffarabad takes diktats from Islamabad and Rawalpindi and the local Kashmiris cannot even demand basic facilities for themselves. Even on Wednesday the protesters had gathered to demand the completion of Tuli Pir Road but the Pakistan Army and ISI do not allow even these protests.